hey guys! Great question and honestly the reason I am answering is because it seems like you have thought this out and done some of your own research. I currently own 4 properties. 2 in my personal name and 2 in my LLC. 12 units total. A future SFR (my current home) in my name, a duplex (former house hack) in my name, a 5 unit property in the LLC, and a 4 unit in the LLC.
Your thoughts on the LLC and more restrictive financing has 100% been my experience too. I have a W2 job and a bank here that has told me they will write my LLC as many mortgages as I want as long as I bring 25% for a down payment. They dont care where the 25% comes from (my cash, 3rd party investors cash, seller carryback mortgage, etc), which is awesome that they are willing to let me get creative, but they also will only do a 15 yr mortgage with a 5.59% (the rate I got on the 4 unit last Nov., its higher now) and the interest rate resets every 5 years during the term. Pretty difficult to get any significant cash flow in my area on the smaller properties (hence why they are both in my name with 30 year fixed at under 4%). The LLC has a lot of benefits (asset protection, anonymity to some degree, etc.), but it also has a lot of drawbacks. The biggest one probably being the financing. The bank my LLC primarily works with is awesome because it is like a well of money that if I meet their requirements they will lend all day! When I was last looking for financing (in Nov) I wanted to make sure that I couldnt find a better bank now that I have more experience. I met with several commercial lenders from several local banks. Most werent really interested in lending to me on individual properties but would rather me refi and consolidate with me once I get a handful of properties. i.e. get 4 or so properties in the LLC and then they will put one mortgage on all of the properties (combining the collateral). At that time they were willing to do 25 year terms if I remember right it was with the same 5 year interest rate resets. I think what I like about the LLC is the lending restrictions actually requires me to find (and negotiate) great deals. It keeps me from not wasting my down payment money on mediocre deals. If I can get a good cash flow (running conservative numbers) on the strict 15 year terms, I will likely always be able to make the property cash flow under any lending environment. I also like the idea that in 15 years it will be all equity and I can 1031 it into a MUCH larger property. I do think (from what I have pieced together from listening to all the BP podcasts) that part of Brandon Turners strategy was buying in his personal name and then transferring it into his LLC after he has it financed in his personal name. I have thought about this with my SFR and duplex, but I am admittedly worried about the due on sale clause. I even called the one mortgage holder and told them I was moving the property into my single member LLC, which they promptly told me they only invest in residential mortgages and if I switch the title to an LLC they will call the due on sale clause. I didnt feel like pushing it, so I didnt change anything.
I am interested in hearing what others think and have experienced.