Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Justin Goodin

Justin Goodin has started 180 posts and replied 960 times.

Post: šŸ‘‹Don't invest until you ask these 38 critical questions

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Corby Goade:

38 questions? Seems like a recipe for analysis paralysis. Honestly, investing in real estate is so much simpler than most people think it is, which I think is what keeps newbies from making moves. They think they're missing something because they don't believe it could be as simple as it appears. 


These questions are not about 'analysis paralysis.' They are worthwhile questions to ask a sponsor before passively investing in a syndication. I hope that helps clarify.

Post: šŸ‘‹Don't invest until you ask these 38 critical questions

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Michael Thach:

I think if you ask this 38 questions, you will never start doing real estate. Maybe I am just lucky or very naive. Of course some of the questions need to be asked... but this 38 questions is an overkill. 

People asking this 38 questions and would decline a deal because 1-2 questions are not positive. I recommend a savings account with 0.5% interest. 


 These questions are not about 'getting started in real estate.' They are worthwhile questions to ask a sponsor before passively investing in a syndication. I hope that helps clarify.

Post: šŸ‘‹Don't invest until you ask these 38 critical questions

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752

Never invest a dime in a real estate deal until you ask these 38 critical questions:

1. What happens if you get hit by a bus?
2. What do you project the stabilized occupancy to be?
3. Whatā€™s the median income for current tenants?
4. Whatā€™s the business plan?
5. What are the projected premiums for renovated units?
6. How did you come up with the projected premiums?
7. How much money are you raising for this project?
8. How much of that is for the down payment?
9. How much of that is for cap-ex (capital expenditures)?
10. What is the overall equity multiple?
11. What are the equity splits?
12. Is there a preferred return? Why or why not?
13. How often do you pay out investor distributions ā€“ monthly, quarterly?
14. Whatā€™s the projected hold time for this project?
15. How did you come up with that timeline?
16. What if the market is soft when the projected hold time ends?
17. How are investors kept up with the progress?
18. Are you taking an acquisition fee?
19. Are you taking an asset management fee?
20. Is there a refinance fee?
21. Is there a disposition fee?
22. What would happen if I had an emergency and needed access to my funds?
23. Who is the property manager?
24. How many deals have they managed like this?
25. Have you worked with this property manager before?
26. Why is the owner selling?
27. How did you find this deal?
28. How much experience do you have with this asset class?
29. What is the total loan amount?
30. What kind of loan are you getting?
31. Is the debt recourse or non-recourse?
32. What are the terms on the loan?
33. What is the LTV (loan-to-value) ratio?
34. What is the debt coverage ratio in year 1?
35. Did you walk the property?
36. Who is on the team?
37. What are their roles and responsibilities?
38. Have you done deals together as a team before?

When you are investing your hard earned capital into a real estate deal, there are no dumb questions.

Every investment has risk. Just make sure you understand the deal and who's running the investment.

What would you add to this list?

Post: šŸ‘‹ 8% preferred return, doesn't mean you receive 8% any year.

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752

Truth: An 8% preferred return, doesn't mean you receive 8% any year.

The preferred return in real estate syndications alludes to the precedence of limited partners receiving a specified return, BEFORE the general partners share in the profits.

// A preferred return (Pref) is not a guarantee or claim that you will get X% in any given year.

How much (or how little) the project cash flows, will determine what you receive on a quarterly basis.

šŸ¢Example:
- $100K investment
- 8% pref

Year 1: You receive $2,000 (2%)
6% is accrued

Year 2: You receive $4,000 (4%)
10% is accrued

Year 3: You receive $6,000 (6%)
12% is accrued

Sale: Pref is caught up with sale proceeds. Then General Partners can share in profits.

Itā€™s not unusual for syndications to roll over a balance right into the sale of the property. The profits from the sale are then redistributed with priority given to catching up on any missed preferred distributions.
- -

āœ… Bottom Line: If a sponsor is offering a preferred return, it does not mean you will receive that % every year in distributions. This is NOT a bad thing and pretty common with real estate syndications.

Did you know this before reading this post? Let me know what you think about this in the comments šŸ‘‡

Post: Commercial real estate mentor. Is 50% until $500k a normal cost?

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752

Sometimes I canā€™t tell if we are in the commercial multifamily industry or the commercial coaching industry šŸ˜…

Post: šŸ‘‹Capital Calls: What Investors Should Do

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Evan Polaski:

In the traditional syndication model that many here are used to, this is good advice, with an emphasis on READ BEFORE YOU SIGN.  Some syndicators will simply dilute your ownership if an LP does not answer a capital call.  But others, effectively default your entire investment and may have rights to claim all funded capital, or a substantial portion of your capital, by choosing not to answer a capital call.  Unfortunately, if you don't read this and confirm it ON YOUR OWN before signing, you may find out too late.  


Additionally, while you should ask questions, as Justin points out, most well written documents have some form of indemnification that basically says the investor is relying SOLELY on the signed documents and any communication prior to that is not considered valid.  I.e. if you asked the syndicator in email how capital calls are handled if you don't fund and they respond "your ownership will be diluted", but the docs say your ownership will be relinquished: the docs are right.

And along the lines of needing more capital when things aren't going as planned, as an LP I would highly recommend you understand the rights of the GP to bring in pref equity ahead of your capital and/or make loans to the property/deal from their own pocket, also placing that capital in priority ahead of the LPs. While these may be viewed as a better alternative than an LP capital call, they can also be used as ways to make a deal appear that it is in better shape than it actually is. I highly recommend any potential LP require their syndications to share: Income statement, including all partnership level expenses, Statement of Cash Flow and Balance Sheet. As an LP, you should be able watch the movement of money in and out of a deal with these statements. I have seen many groups simply share the Income Statement down to NOI, which is not an adequate way to monitor the financial health of any type of deal (syndication or otherwise).


 Wow! Amazing points. Thanks for mentioning this. 
I totally agree that GPs should make the complete financial statements available to view. I would think only sophisticated LPs would be able to make their way through these. But not a bad idea at all to ask. 

Post: šŸ‘‹Capital Calls: What Investors Should Do

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752

First, let's define what this is:

A capital call (aka cash call) is the process when the general partner(s) attempts to collect additional funds from their investors to supplement the financing for a real estate project or transaction. This is done when a multifamily property needs more capital than originally anticipated to sustain operations.

Capital calls can indicate the investment is not as sound as investors originally thought, and is potentially at risk of falling apart. As such, capital calls can have a negative connotation among real estate investors.

 -- 

Due to the fact that capital calls usually require real estate investors to provide additional funds within a short time period, they can be seen as a source of financial burden and stress since investors may not have the necessary funds available.

Unexpected capital calls also indicate their investment is not as sound as they first thought and is potentially at risk of falling apart. As such, capital calls can have a negative connotation among real estate investors.

// So what should you do if a sponsor performs a capital call on a deal you are invested in?

Step 1: Read The Operating Agreement

If you invested in the offering, you read (or should have read) and signed the operating agreement. The operating agreement explains exactly how capital calls work for the deal you invested in. 

Step 2: Seek Professional Advice

Passive investors should seek professional advice from their attorney. Most likely, your attorney will ask what the operating agreement specifies (step 1). Comment below the name of your favorite attorney!

Step 3: Ask Questions

This is the time to ask the general partner(s) any and all questions. At this point, the general partner(s) should be over communicating with the investors and keeping them up-to-date with what is going on. Either monthly, weekly, or even daily.

The general partner(s) should have communicated the reason for the capital call, exactly what the money will be spent on, and outlined their proposed plan to success.

Post: $50,000 down to make $3,000/month

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Ryan Ness:

This is awesome! I am looking at duplexes that would require that much down for just conventional financing. Did you have a certain plan you implemented to come across this deal? I am currently exploring networking opportunities to source deals like this!


I found this deal from a cold email.  

Post: Multi-Family Deal Analyzer

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Brady Tome:
Quote from @Justin Goodin:
Quote from @Brady Tome:

Hello all,

I am currently searching for my first multi-family investment property. I've been using the basic Google mortgage calculator, but I want to know if there are any other tools I can use to get a more detailed assessment of the deal or the maximum amount I can pay. Thanks.

Iā€™ll send you a multifamily underwriting model I created for free. Let me know if you want it!

 Yeah always open to trying new tools. Send it over appreciate it man


 DM me where I can email it. 

Post: Multi-Family Deal Analyzer

Justin GoodinPosted
  • Investor
  • Indianapolis, IN
  • Posts 1,026
  • Votes 752
Quote from @Brady Tome:

Hello all,

I am currently searching for my first multi-family investment property. I've been using the basic Google mortgage calculator, but I want to know if there are any other tools I can use to get a more detailed assessment of the deal or the maximum amount I can pay. Thanks.

Iā€™ll send you a multifamily underwriting model I created for free. Let me know if you want it!