Posting a 3-year follow-up on this property if anyone is interested!
It will have to be abbreviated, because it's been a long, winding road since then.
Shocker that will shock no one... I went WAY over budget on the rehab. I had it budgeted at $30K, gave myself $40K as wiggle room and ended up at $53K (including all holding costs.)
From the day I purchased it until the day someone moved in, 13 months elapsed. I even managed to fit in getting pregnant and birthing a child inside that same time window!
So, total cost to own came to $95,060. Anyone who buys and rents houses in Belair-Edision will know that is way too high.
In Nov 2017, we had a section 8 tenant lined up to move in at $1400/mo. That ended up falling through (after we did a number of additional section 8 required repairs) and my property managers placed a market rate tenant at $1275/mo in Dec 2017.
That tenant is still there and the PM is looking to extend their lease again.
I'm pretty sure the property will be in utter disrepair when they move out (just a hunch I get when I talk to my PM), so I basically hope they will never leave.
My property managers have been the saving grace in this situation (from allowing me to not have to show a property when I was 9 months pregnant to affordably and promptly fixing each and every little thing)
So, was this a cash cow? No. Has the demand for properties gone up in 21213 since I bought it? Hell yeah. Did I learn a lot? Ah yes. Am I still spending too much on rehabbing other properties? Also yes.
I could likely sell this one for $85K (give or take) now, but I'm thinking I'll hold on. I've been entertaining a cash-out refi for quite a while now and may bite the bullet on that soon. Banks' appetite for risk has lessened in the last couple months and rates on them are not great.
I've since acquired 5 more units in Baltimore City and County.
So that's where we're at in the saga, folks!