Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Joy D.

Joy D. has started 1 posts and replied 16 times.

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Mad props to you Jorge for weighing in with your expertise and total cost ballpark estimate!!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
Quote from @Joy D.:

 You're being smart!

Thanks!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:

There is one unethical hack I've seen for the floor issue -- calling the garage conversion a "storage conversion" (not classifying it for living purposes). I think it depends on the department and could lead to liability issues, but I've seen it done.

Oh yeah, this will get people in serious trouble :-) .....dodging the 'living space conversion' by calling it 'storage space'. All it takes is a neighbor to call or a city official stopping by on unrelated issues. Municipalities really do not like it when you lie to them about living space. At least that was my experience.....

Agree. I would never do it. But this is Florida. Most people in my local area don't even have their ADUs permitted, so even a storage conversion permit is a step up :D

Haha! True words! THIS is FLORIDA, and it's hard times out here. I'll probably be one of a tiny handful of permitted garage conversions in my neighborhood.

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:
Quote from @Joy D.:
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:

Def worth a shot to save 4k. Only other thing I can think of that would constitute a structural mod would be if the floor of the garage needed to be raised and if it were to be done via framing vs overpour. Any time I've done an addition, I had to raise the floor to match the rest of the house.

There is one unethical hack I've seen for the floor issue -- calling the garage conversion a "storage conversion" (not classifying it for living purposes). I think it depends on the department and could lead to liability issues, but I've seen it done.

Framing is done with plywood right? And overpour is when you get the truck to pour in the cement? Is one method better than the other? And I'm assuming there are cost implications that vary with either? Hmm... seems like framing a floor vs cement could lead to moisture issues (or maybe not otherwise why would they allow that option)... Any thoughts on this?

 The homeowner / contractor trying to save money on a project will go the framing route. I always opt for overpour, but it can be quite costly. Concrete work is expensive.

Thanks, Jeff. I'll get some price estimates and weight out my options. Love getting info from all sides of this!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
Quote from @Joy D.:

If you go the wood framing route you will have to rip the joists that sit on the concrete because garage floors are built with a slope (for water runoff). This can be a PITA unless you have a good Contractor/Framer. You'll also have to seal the existing concrete with some sort of vapor barrier.

Easier to just go the concrete route....


Much appreciated!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:

Def worth a shot to save 4k. Only other thing I can think of that would constitute a structural mod would be if the floor of the garage needed to be raised and if it were to be done via framing vs overpour. Any time I've done an addition, I had to raise the floor to match the rest of the house.

There is one unethical hack I've seen for the floor issue -- calling the garage conversion a "storage conversion" (not classifying it for living purposes). I think it depends on the department and could lead to liability issues, but I've seen it done.

Framing is done with plywood right? And overpour is when you get the truck to pour in the cement? Is one method better than the other? And I'm assuming there are cost implications that vary with either? Hmm... seems like framing a floor vs cement could lead to moisture issues (or maybe not otherwise why would they allow that option)... Any thoughts on this?

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3

Henry, your "We're not building the Empire State building" comment took me out! LOL! Thanks for sharing your knowledge on the process and for outlining some of the mandatory things that code departments will likely need across the board, regardless of where you are. And it's so helpful you shared how it went with your drafter and the items they needed to get you going. I appreciate you simplifying what can be a complex process. I think I'm getting the gist of this... I'm going to find out from the city: if I need a survey for my garage project, if raising the floor constitutes a structural change (city requires I elevate the floor), and I want solid confirmation on whether signatures and/or seals are needed for my modest garage remodel.

Thanks for the intel, Henry!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Wait... WHUT?! Jeff... hands down, you're the BP MVP of the month in my book!! (lol) What a clever hack! Thank you for sharing that tip.. this is what I've been after, short of knocking on the doors of garage-convo homes I see in my neighborhood... and I'm not that bold so this is SO appreciated!!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3
Quote from @Jeff Hagen:
Quote from @Henry T.:

Piece of cake. I've done this at a few properties. my last project I hired a drafter rather than an architect. His drawings sailed right thru the permit office. There was no structural changes involved, so no structural engineer. The city even had a little handout for garage conversion, pertaining to achieving the proper R value for an in place slab. For cost reasons I called it a remodel rather than an ADU. This saved around $50k of charges for sewer impact fees and separate electric meter(who wants another bill? not me). You can buy these little meters that attach to your sub panel, if you want to know how much elec the unit is using. My biggest surprise on this last project was that they allowed standard 1/2" sheetrock for fire wall. In the past it's always been 5/8". I was stunned. Not saying you should, check first of course.

Depends heavily on the AHJ where you're located and whether or not you have a pre-existing relationship with them. Since you're speaking to a 50k impact fee, that sounds like you're on the west coast. Here in FL, you can build out an ADU for under 3k in total fees. The electric company installed the new meter for free after giving me a credit for adding laying the conduit required for the 200amp to 400amp upgrade.

As for the 1/2" (non fire code) gyp, my understanding of the code is that a 1 hour rated assembly is required between "dwelling units." However, if you labeled it as an addition (not a separate dwelling unit), code only requires 30 minute fire assembly (1/2 gyp) between sleeping units (bedrooms). But for the safety of the occupants, the up charge to go to 5/8" is pretty minimal.

And so with this knowledge, I'd likely look into the 5/8" upgrade!

Post: Garage Conversion to Living Space

Joy D.Posted
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 3

Whoa! I didn't know I could meet with the inspectors! And I already have both an existing exterior side door and a big window that is the same size as the windows in my bed room, so I'm assuming they all meet.the egress reqs. Jeeze Jeff, you are a life-saver!! Oh and yes... they told me for sure that I must raise the floor per my city's requirements... is that considered a structural change?