Hi @Kevin Ochs! I'm in a similar situation to you. Married, living in Noblesville (Moved here in 2018), and I've spent 5 of my last 10 years working in Insurance/Financial Services. Currently I am working as a media director (I know, wide swing, but I've also worked in media as a self-employed individual for the other 5 of the last 10 years of work.)
I lived in Western NY (Not the fun part of NY) prior to moving here, and bought what I considered a live-in flip while I was out there. Sanded and stained the hardwood floors, laid tile in the bathroom and kitchen, installed recessed lighting in the living room, switched out all the outlets, painted everything, refinished the bathroom completely. Was able to learn a lot through the process.
The house we bought here was in great shape, just had no updates to it at all. We've installed recessed lighting throughout the house (hired that out this time), installed LVP flooring (did it ourselves), and replaced the entire HVAC (hired out). The neighborhood has appreciated a lot even in the short time we've been here so we haven't felt bad on the time/money tradeoff of hiring some of that out.
My goal is to purchase 2 rental properties in 2021. Would love to connect sometime! Best of luck!