Originally posted by @Brandon Hall:
Jon Mason I'm struggling to understand your numbers here. You say it will rent for $2100 and your payment will potentially be $1200. That's a $900 net difference that you are looking at which isn't bad, you just need to make sure your numbers are accurate.
You say you want to find a place to rent so that you can save up for a downpayment. How much will rent cost you per month? How much of that $900 will be remaining to actually save? **Edit: How much of the $1400 payment you no longer have will you be able to save?** It's very hard for people to downgrade, so keep that in mind.
Additionally, has the property seen any appreciation since you've owned it? If so, you will want to factor the section 121 capital gains exclusion into your decision making.
My $500 figure was assuming I couldn't get PMI removed, so $1400 mortgage payment, and assuming the conservative end of the rent figures I mentioned, so $1900 rent. If that were the case, it would be $500 per month left over. You are correct though, if I could get PMI removed, and rent it for $2100, there would $900 left over.
All of the money we'd make on the rental would be saved, at least for the time being. Of course later we may want to put some of that into another property or something. Rent on an apartment would be like, $1000 probably (haven't looked around a lot yet). I failed to mention that the the primary goal of this wouldn't be for immediate cashflow (although I hope it makes money, obviously), but for long-term wealth building. As it currently stands, we could pay the mortgage on this house and rent an apartment in addition to that on our current income and still be fine. It wouldn't be ideal, but it wouldn't ruin us by any stretch.
As far as appreciation, we bought the house for $234K about 2 years ago and we owe $212. Zillow's estimate says it's worth $265, but again, I don't know how accurate that is.