For a little more detail...
When I say the house is nicer than its surroundings, I mean that the bones, floorplan, and layout were all originally GREAT, but the cosmetics were in bad shape. It's also larger in terms of square footage some of the other houses on the market.
Regarding the rehab, I feel like a cut every corner possible, haha. I used bargain materials, kept as much original material as possible (e.g., painting cabinets rather than replacing), and so forth. So when I say it looks GREAT, I mean it looks great for the amount I spent (or didn't spend) on it.
Most of the flips I've seen on the market in the area are on the same level as far as rehab goes. The comp down the street (also someone's flip) was similar in terms of size and rehab.
I'm inclined to agree with what all of you are saying though - if no one is biting, it's priced too high. I think a price drop is my next step. Just trying to get a feel for what everyone's protocol is for this kind of thing.
Thanks everyone for your input so far! Any additional suggestions or feedback would be welcome!