Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Jonathan Greene

Jonathan Greene has started 266 posts and replied 6422 times.

Post: Are the forums on BiggerPockets getting worse and worse or is it just me?

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Scott Mac:

It might be the investing environment.

Right now we have a different interest rate picture then we had a few years ago.

Also in many areas prices are very high.

Meaning the low hanging fruit for a new investor might be a little higher up on the tree and fewer and farther between.

And I also see many questions popping up about running a short term rental business, which to me is more of a business than an investment although it does involve an investment in real estate.


Great point about the low-hanging fruit being harder to reach. I just feel like many people have no will to try to ask a really good question anymore.

Post: Are the forums on BiggerPockets getting worse and worse or is it just me?

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598

I find them almost unreadable now. Finding a good post to respond to takes me close to ten minutes. There is so much AI, reverse trolling, and one-line posts that the moderators can't keep up. And I know because I was a moderator for a couple of months, but I quit.

Being a moderator on the site is thankless. There are no benefits, no pay. Whenever you remove a post, you have a 10-20 percent chance that the poster will email you to complain. It's not fun, but it helps the site a lot. However, there aren't enough moderators to do the job against technology and spammers now. This is part of why the forums are pretty vapid, significantly more so than they used to be. When you give the benefit of the doubt to garbage posts, it creates a pile of trash, making it harder to find the collectibles.

The company's target audience is new investors. Old investors like me only invest in the subscription for pro; we don't buy courses or books (actually, I own probably 20 of their books) regularly. So, the focus on new investors creates allowable concessions in favor of new people, but that doesn't improve the forums. "We all had to start somewhere" is true, but the forums used to be more fun when people weren't as fragile as they are now. When you tell someone their strategy isn't brilliant, they melt into an offended state and fry themselves in their forum.

Are the forums here getting worse, or is it just me? Maybe I am just getting too old to wade through AI posts to try to help someone. I can't even look at the Facebook group because it is the forums x 10. I still want to help, but the time to find something interesting is getting too long for me.

Thoughts?

Post: Why is Zillow so bad?

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598

I worked with Zillow for years. My team was on Zillow Flex. They are a platform that has no identity and doesn't really know what they are doing or who they are serving. They make their money off of real estate agents, but real estate agents are the worst people to make money off because they are highly unreliable and in and out of the business when the market changes.

Their target should be the consumer with higher levels that they can subscribe too for data, since Zillow is linked to the MLS now which makes their data somewhere more reliable. But consumers all are on the site for free where real estate agents are constantly hawked to buy leads or participate in what is now a 35-40% referral business for unvetted leads who think they are contacting the listing agent.

Their business model has always been flawed. I gave them consistent feedback for years and still believe they could have made $10m or more off of my ideas. Instead, they bought homes and lost money, then acquired Open Door and lost money. There is no one with experience in actual real estate high up in the company, which is the problem with most tech companies masquerading as real estate companies (including brokerages).

Let me know if you want to know even more. :)

Post: Why are Newbies Using Invalid Investment Assumptions from 5+ Years Ago?

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598

This is why so many new investors are saying they are going to BRRRR properties, not knowing that, in many markets, it doesn't work right now with high prices, low inventory, and higher rates. And of course, they can't find a deal that pencils.

Nothing is absolute, there are deals everywhere still if you keep digging.

Post: Subto FHA problem

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:
Quote from @Steve K.:
Quote from @Alex Hall:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Zach Howard:

@Ken M.

Where and how can I most efficiently learn about subto in full detail? Any recommended reading materials, please. 

Thanks. 


 If you are not well capitalized, meaning you can not pay off the loan if called, stay away from sub to. 


 Yes, I've heard this before and therefore, for the time being, if I get involved in any sub to deals, I'll keep them within the 200k limit (as I can pay this off if push comes to shove).

However, I would still like to learn more about sub to, any guidance concerning reading materials would be greatly appreciated. 

My concern is that you seem to be out of country. Subto is unpredictable in how it proceeds and 6 months down the road it could flare up. There really isn't a safe, secure way for someone to protect their interests. Even if buying a property Subto in GA and you live in FL, you could miss something and the whole deal does a "crash and burn". How available are you to fly into the state the property is in and deal with it? Are you a US citizen who understands how things work legally in the USA? 

 Perhaps valid concerns. I don't see how they relate to wanting to educate myself or asking for reading recommendations. 


Zach, If you search Pace Morby on YouTube. He has an entire community that he teaches. He puts a lot of free content out there to learn from. 


 When his followers came on here about a year ago and spammed these forums with cult-like nonsense posts, I tried to watch a few videos of his and realized right away that a lot of what he was saying is very questionable. Whenever someone contradicts themselves in the first 30 seconds of a video, it makes me question everything they say after that. 

This is the 2nd thread recently where people espousing his teachings have had issues using sub2 (see the recent one here from someone who was warned about the high risk of the strategies he teaches about a year ago but said he should be trusted "because he had a TV show on A&E": https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/50/topics/1225630-due-o... can't make this stuff up). I expect there will be many more issues with these transactions moving forward. 

Sub2 is a risky strategy for a long term buy and hold as the longer the deal structure stays in place, the higher the chance that issues will arise (like issues with the loan servicer, insurance, seller filing for bankruptcy, seller dying, seller realizing their DTI ratio and ability to buy their next property is negatively effected and becoming upset about it like in your case, due on sale clause being called, etc.). Much better as a short term acquisition strategy for flips IMO but always a high-risk strategy that should not be practiced by anyone who doesn't have the liquid capital to pay off the loan if needed. Just my opinion.


All of this. Personally, I like Pace and think he is a smart guy who cares about helping people, but the empire has overtaken the vision. The SubTo community has become bro-fueled tupperware sales and Acme/Avon downlines.

Anything creative is best done with complete transparency and the entire premise of SubTo is not transparent. It's rarely fully transparent to the seller and never to the original lender. A lot of people get themselves in trouble by acting as a conduit to mild fraud or just general deceit within the rules.

.

Hmmm, he is bragging all over Youtube how he is making $150,000 from one guy's equity, on one transaction, by bailing him out of foreclosure.

Who is he "helping"?

In fact, he says he transferred the title to himself, to "protect" his "investment". He is encouraging his tribe to send him leads so he can do more of these. He is polluting subto. No wonder he is disliked on Bigger Pockets. 


I mean originally, not now. Now it's an out of control machine with a lot of financial incestuous relationship in the tupperware farm.

I like your analogy. It's spot on. In an interview with Grant Cardone, (who has an entirely different perspective on things than I do ;-) Morby said he wants to be a billionaire. That's quite a goal. It appears he is on a course of actions that will not change.

The pyramid scheme became obvious when the underlings started to reign down in the forums here, as many mentioned, where no one looks too kindly on SubTo, not knowing what they were walking into and not caring because they were looking for the "hungry" bros who would spend the $8,800 to get into the community and "share" deals. There is a way to do it with respect to all parties, but that's not why people are signing up. They are signing up because they want to be a billionaire and follow in the footsteps, which is literally insane to think you can do that with SubTo.

Post: Subto FHA problem

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:
Quote from @Steve K.:
Quote from @Alex Hall:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Zach Howard:

@Ken M.

Where and how can I most efficiently learn about subto in full detail? Any recommended reading materials, please. 

Thanks. 


 If you are not well capitalized, meaning you can not pay off the loan if called, stay away from sub to. 


 Yes, I've heard this before and therefore, for the time being, if I get involved in any sub to deals, I'll keep them within the 200k limit (as I can pay this off if push comes to shove).

However, I would still like to learn more about sub to, any guidance concerning reading materials would be greatly appreciated. 

My concern is that you seem to be out of country. Subto is unpredictable in how it proceeds and 6 months down the road it could flare up. There really isn't a safe, secure way for someone to protect their interests. Even if buying a property Subto in GA and you live in FL, you could miss something and the whole deal does a "crash and burn". How available are you to fly into the state the property is in and deal with it? Are you a US citizen who understands how things work legally in the USA? 

 Perhaps valid concerns. I don't see how they relate to wanting to educate myself or asking for reading recommendations. 


Zach, If you search Pace Morby on YouTube. He has an entire community that he teaches. He puts a lot of free content out there to learn from. 


 When his followers came on here about a year ago and spammed these forums with cult-like nonsense posts, I tried to watch a few videos of his and realized right away that a lot of what he was saying is very questionable. Whenever someone contradicts themselves in the first 30 seconds of a video, it makes me question everything they say after that. 

This is the 2nd thread recently where people espousing his teachings have had issues using sub2 (see the recent one here from someone who was warned about the high risk of the strategies he teaches about a year ago but said he should be trusted "because he had a TV show on A&E": https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/50/topics/1225630-due-o... can't make this stuff up). I expect there will be many more issues with these transactions moving forward. 

Sub2 is a risky strategy for a long term buy and hold as the longer the deal structure stays in place, the higher the chance that issues will arise (like issues with the loan servicer, insurance, seller filing for bankruptcy, seller dying, seller realizing their DTI ratio and ability to buy their next property is negatively effected and becoming upset about it like in your case, due on sale clause being called, etc.). Much better as a short term acquisition strategy for flips IMO but always a high-risk strategy that should not be practiced by anyone who doesn't have the liquid capital to pay off the loan if needed. Just my opinion.


All of this. Personally, I like Pace and think he is a smart guy who cares about helping people, but the empire has overtaken the vision. The SubTo community has become bro-fueled tupperware sales and Acme/Avon downlines.

Anything creative is best done with complete transparency and the entire premise of SubTo is not transparent. It's rarely fully transparent to the seller and never to the original lender. A lot of people get themselves in trouble by acting as a conduit to mild fraud or just general deceit within the rules.

.

Hmmm, he is bragging all over Youtube how he is making $150,000 from one guy's equity, on one transaction, by bailing him out of foreclosure.

Who is he "helping"?

In fact, he says he transferred the title to himself, to "protect" his "investment". He is encouraging his tribe to send him leads so he can do more of these. He is polluting subto. No wonder he is disliked on Bigger Pockets. 

I mean originally, not now. Now it's an out of control machine with a lot of financially incestuous relationships in the tupperware farm.

Post: Subto FHA problem

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Steve K.:
Quote from @Alex Hall:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Zach Howard:
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Zach Howard:

@Ken M.

Where and how can I most efficiently learn about subto in full detail? Any recommended reading materials, please. 

Thanks. 


 If you are not well capitalized, meaning you can not pay off the loan if called, stay away from sub to. 


 Yes, I've heard this before and therefore, for the time being, if I get involved in any sub to deals, I'll keep them within the 200k limit (as I can pay this off if push comes to shove).

However, I would still like to learn more about sub to, any guidance concerning reading materials would be greatly appreciated. 

My concern is that you seem to be out of country. Subto is unpredictable in how it proceeds and 6 months down the road it could flare up. There really isn't a safe, secure way for someone to protect their interests. Even if buying a property Subto in GA and you live in FL, you could miss something and the whole deal does a "crash and burn". How available are you to fly into the state the property is in and deal with it? Are you a US citizen who understands how things work legally in the USA? 

 Perhaps valid concerns. I don't see how they relate to wanting to educate myself or asking for reading recommendations. 


Zach, If you search Pace Morby on YouTube. He has an entire community that he teaches. He puts a lot of free content out there to learn from. 


 When his followers came on here about a year ago and spammed these forums with cult-like nonsense posts, I tried to watch a few videos of his and realized right away that a lot of what he was saying is very questionable. Whenever someone contradicts themselves in the first 30 seconds of a video, it makes me question everything they say after that. 

This is the 2nd thread recently where people espousing his teachings have had issues using sub2 (see the recent one here from someone who was warned about the high risk of the strategies he teaches about a year ago but said he should be trusted "because he had a TV show on A&E": https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/50/topics/1225630-due-o... can't make this stuff up). I expect there will be many more issues with these transactions moving forward. 

Sub2 is a risky strategy for a long term buy and hold as the longer the deal structure stays in place, the higher the chance that issues will arise (like issues with the loan servicer, insurance, seller filing for bankruptcy, seller dying, seller realizing their DTI ratio and ability to buy their next property is negatively effected and becoming upset about it like in your case, due on sale clause being called, etc.). Much better as a short term acquisition strategy for flips IMO but always a high-risk strategy that should not be practiced by anyone who doesn't have the liquid capital to pay off the loan if needed. Just my opinion.


All of this. Personally, I like Pace and think he is a smart guy who cares about helping people, but the empire has overtaken the vision. The SubTo community has become bro-fueled tupperware sales and Acme/Avon downlines.

Anything creative is best done with complete transparency and the entire premise of SubTo is not transparent. It's rarely fully transparent to the seller and never to the original lender. A lot of people get themselves in trouble by acting as a conduit to mild fraud or just general deceit within the rules.

Post: Tenant with medical marijuana card. What are my options?

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Josh Ball:
Quote from @Jonathan Greene:

Smokers aren't a protected class, but they could argue that whatever the underlying "medical" issue for the card could be part of one. It seems like the tenant is being respectful, following the rules, and is not being a problem so I think that is what you would tell any other tenants who ask, as long as you have seen the card. If you got a report that someone was smoking cigarettes or cigars outside only, per the rules, would you post the same question?

Thanks for the advice. Certainly will be sure to ask to see the card before signing an official agreement.

Wouldn't be asking about cigarettes or cigars. I don't see it as an issue but many still do, at least in my small town where the majority of renters are elderly people looking for low maintenance housing options. That is where the concern would be for me.


Yeah, older tenants may think that it automatically makes someone a criminal of something, but I would just explain the card and that it at least, in theory, has a medical purpose, unlike cigarette smoke which kills the smokers and everyone else around.

Post: Property managers allowed unsupervised showings, resulting in theft

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598
Quote from @Account Closed:

Hello! After years of self-managing our single-family rentals, we decided to hire a property manager to provide full service management. I understand that it's unrealistic to expect anyone to treat your property with the same level of care you would, but the company we hired has been a NIGHTMARE. 

The most concerning is that they allowed unsupervised showings on a vacant unit- something we were not aware of until serious theft had occurred. The details of the incident remain unclear, but they intentionally granted access to someone who subsequently stole major appliances. The management company replaced some of them, however there are still several other fees related to the theft that we are trying to get reimbursed for (they told us we would not be charged, they charged us anyways). There are several other issues (undisclosed maintenance markup fees, excessive charges to our account, significant reductions to agreed rent without communication, etc). We have a PMA, but it doesn't  seem to address these things in a way that is specific enough to where they're violating the agreement. I am wondering if anyone has ever taken legal action against property managers, and if they think we have a potential case? I hate to go that direction, but their negligence has cost us thousands. Thanks in advance!


What due diligence did you do before hiring them? You should fire them right away and talk to an attorney to prevent the loss, but I wouldn't expect much and it could be a waste since a company that does this will not have the money to do anything.

When you have just one unit and you are looking for PM companies, your options are the bottom of the barrel because it's not a good use of the big one's time.

Post: "Multi-family" agents-how to pick one's

Jonathan Greene
#5 Starting Out Contributor
Posted
  • Real Estate Consultant
  • Mendham, NJ
  • Posts 6,630
  • Votes 7,598

That's a horrendous fallacy and a weak mindset to think that real estate agents are buying the best multis. More than 90 percent of real estate agents are out of the business in less than five years. Less than 2% even own real estate. Most real estate agents do less than two deals per year. The smart ones house hack and buy rentals, but the good ones know that their clients come first. You want to find a balance of investing experience, but strong track record of multifamily sales (which you can see on their Zillow profile).