Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: John Schaeffer

John Schaeffer has started 1 posts and replied 65 times.

Post: Landlord insurance with rent protection

John SchaefferPosted
  • Posts 70
  • Votes 26

This is 100% an urban legend!

Quote from @Doug Newman:

Oh, OK. I live in Colorado where roofs are a huge issue.

My team, based near Denver, tends to stay away from the northeast because of state regulations.


 It's crazy everywhere! I have a couple contacts that do insurance in Colorado and they're ready to pull their hair out.

Quote from @Ryan Muska:
Quote from @John Schaeffer:
Quote from @Ryan Muska:

I learned this the hard way.

After getting my house closed on. The next week I got a letter from Travelers saying that my insurance was being cancelled. Luckily I secured new insurance (at a cheaper rate) immediately after, but that was a very stressful few days...


 What was the reason they were cancelling you?


 They said it was due to the condition of the roof...that I just got fixed by the seller.


 Got it. Travelers has restricted their roof age to 15 years which is INSANE considering you can get 25-30 years out of a roof.

I've been placing a lot of homes with Selective Insurance, Safeco Insurance, and Franklin Mutual as they seem to be extremely competitive if it's the right client they're looking for.

You'll want to look anywhere that has a good rail system to Secaucus/NYC as most people are leaving NYC and commuting from the suburbs of Jersey. I recommend looking across the Raritan Valley Line or looking into Warren/Sussex counties as it's a lower cost of living but still within a reasonable driving distance into Manhattan.

Good luck!

Post: Homeowners Insurance Increase

John SchaefferPosted
  • Posts 70
  • Votes 26
Quote from @Andrew Freed:

@Account Closed - Yes, insurance is expected to rise 20-40% this year as a result of the increase in claims that they have been paying out the past few years. This is due to the extremely weather conditions across the US. It rised on one of my multifamilies from 4500 to 5700. One thing you can do is request that your deductible is increased. If you don't plan on filing a claim unless its at least 5k, why pay a premium for a smaller deductible? I did that and it saved me hundreds annually on a few different policies. 


 Agreed, if you're handy and can fix most things yourself OR have a good relationship with a General Contractor that's going to work with you on repairing the property. Raising the deductible is as safe an option as you can go instead of decreasing your coverage.

Congrats on buying your first home!

I second building a solid team especially as you expand your portfolio. You're going to need a good contractor/handyman, CPA to help manage your income's properly, a good real estate attorney, solid title company, and of course a good insurance broker to make sure it's properly covered.


I'd love to connect and assist anyway I can!

Quote from @Ryan Muska:

I learned this the hard way.

After getting my house closed on. The next week I got a letter from Travelers saying that my insurance was being cancelled. Luckily I secured new insurance (at a cheaper rate) immediately after, but that was a very stressful few days...


 What was the reason they were cancelling you?

Post: Homeowners Insurance Increase

John SchaefferPosted
  • Posts 70
  • Votes 26

I'm not in Texas but insurance costs are rising everywhere. From what I hear the Texas insurance market is insanely difficult right now.

I'd call a couple brokers and let them shop the coverage for you but that might be the best you can do.

Quote from @Zachary N.:

Thank you so much for the insight. I guess doing room-to-room is less common that I thought. Assuming that I abandon that model for a whole home rental instead, does anyone have experience with AU Gold (Kraft Lake) and/or Proper Insurance? Those are the two place I will be getting quotes from for a new insurance policy in Southern California.


 AU Gold is a surplus lines carrier meaning they take a lot of insurance risks that standard carriers (think state farm, allstate, progressive etc) won't take.

It might honestly be your best shot and getting some kind of coverage placed.

Post: Looking to be a resource!

John SchaefferPosted
  • Posts 70
  • Votes 26

Hey everyone! 

I'm new to the BP group and so lucky to have been introduced to it by a friend. I'm an insurance broker in NJ and I'd like to offer my services to real estate investors and lenders who may not have that seat filled in their team, are unhappy with their current broker, or didn't even know where to look for someone who can handle all these risks.

Having an insurance agent that is able to protect your investment properly is huge as they are a revenue stream for you and if your coverage is lacking or if it's insured improperly it's going to end up costing you time and money.

The agency I'm with is located in NJ and we are competitive in the tri-state area but we are also able to write policies for all states except for Florida and California right now as those insurance markets are insane.

We can do the 4 major lines of insurance (personal, commercial, life, and health). Looking forward to assisting you if given the opportunity!