Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: John Underwood

John Underwood has started 107 posts and replied 12192 times.

Post: Best Way to Return Left Behind Items?

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028

I send them via USPS with delivery confirmation.

I usually cover the costs, but you could ask to be reimbursed or send you money ahead of time to cover shipping.

Post: how you protect your house in short term rental?

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Itay Heled:
Quote from @John Underwood:
Quote from @Itay Heled:

Hi ,

I just list my house for short term

four  young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks.  the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest.  few days in they asked to add 4 more people. 

hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?

is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people?  send someone to visit the house? 

also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as  booking.com VRBO etc?

thanks !

Itay 


Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it


can you explain please what STR insurance is actually covering what is the cost and what is the deductible to get a sense?


 It varies. You'll need to get several quotes to get prices specific to you property.

Post: how you protect your house in short term rental?

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Itay Heled:

Hi ,

I just list my house for short term

four  young people rent my furnished apartment via Airbnb for two weeks.  the person who rent it has one review . I know nothing about the rest.  few days in they asked to add 4 more people. 

hearing all the horror stories about parties and trashing the house, what are the tricks and ways to minimize the risk?

is it practical and acceptable to do some sort of background checks on the new people?  send someone to visit the house? 

also, Airbnb has some sort of protection but what are you doing with reservations coming from other platforms such as  booking.com VRBO etc?

thanks !

Itay 


Just have the correct STR insurance and don't sweat it

Post: Agent looking to start direct to seller for motivated sellers

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Ken M.:
Quote from @Jerryll Noorden:
Quote from @Kieron Osullivan:
Quote from @Jerryll Noorden:

Try to change the way you think/approach success.

Said it before, will say it again.

A lot of people do this:

Hey… I have 3 wives, 4 girlfriends on the side, 5 dogs, 6 jobs, I can only devote $200 every 5 months, and I have only 2 hours/month available to work on my business… how do I become successful?

Instead, you need to realize that success (or the universe, for that matter) won’t bend backward for you.

Instead of asking how to become successful based on your limitations, you need to turn it around.

First, you need to determine what it takes to become successful!? Then, use what you have to get what it takes to become successful.

If success takes 12 hours a day, $3,000/month on marketing, a solid education, knowledge of marketing, and deal-making—then that is what it takes.

The reason most people struggle is exactly this.

Understand this.

You can’t target motivated sellers. It is absolutely impossible. The reason why? Because no one—and nothing—can predict when someone becomes motivated.

Circumstance (like foreclosure) does not imply motivation. Motivation is an emotional response to a circumstance, not the circumstance itself.

To fully grasp this, you need to understand what a motivated seller actually is.

Many people think a motivated seller is anyone who wants to, needs to, or HAS to sell their house.

That is wrong.

A motivated seller has only one characteristic:

Anyone willing to sell their house below market value. The reason why does not matter.

Take someone in foreclosure.

Do they have to sell? YES.

And if they don’t sell, aren’t they going to be in trouble? YES.

Are they willing to sell below market value? NO.

They’d rather burn the house to the ground out of pure spite than sell to you at market value—let alone at a discount.

Once you understand the basics, you’ll soon realize that the ways everyone tells you to get motivated seller leads are factually, universally wrong.

Not an opinion. Just pure facts.

You can’t target them. They target you.

"You can’t target motivated sellers. It is absolutely impossible. The reason why? Because no one—and nothing—can predict when someone becomes motivated."

I can: when a person is starving and  hasn't eaten a meal in days they are motivated to find food themselves or buy it from someone else. If they dont, eventually they die. 

If I want to sell food i would target starving people because they are motivated by the avoidance of starvation and death.

This is what motivated means according to the English language dictionary:

provide (someone) with a reason for doing something.

Someone whos home is being foreclosed, where they have defaulted and an auction/sale has been set is being given a reason to pay the debt back. If they cant pay off the debt there homes will be sold, they will lose all equity, tarnished credit history and be homeless.

A wholesaler can come in and potentially save credit history, setup a deal to keep them in there home and even structure a deal to get the homeowner some equity back.

The wholesaler/investor would never know this opportunity existed if they di not find a record/notice/document that indicated the home was being foreclosed on. The lead gave them the knowledge and motivation to potentially make a substantial profit and help the borrower. 

This is why people buy leads and lists consisting of records showing people are in the process of losing there homes. The process motivates them to sell.

If they are not motivated to sell to a wholesaler for a lot cheaper because of the legal process they are in, what has made them sell it for less?

No, you can't.

I am going to take a lot of effort here and write something for you and everyone to finally change the way you think.

Pick 1000 people from your favorite Foreclosure list and ask them:
“Do you want to sell your house or would you rather keep it?

1000 out of 1000 will say: “I rather keep it”.

Now take 1000 people from your favorite Tax Lien list and ask them the same question:

Do you want to sell your house or would you rather keep it?

They’ll say: “I rather keep it”.

Ask anyone on any of your lists the exact same question and the answer will be the same. You are going after people who explicitly rather keep their house than sell it, to try to convince them to sell it. Really really REALLY Stupid, no?

This is equivalent to buying a list of vegans, to try sell them baby-cow burgers.

Now, Hold that thought…

I’m going to give you facts, not opinions. After reading this, do whatever you want with it—but don’t argue with me (please). It will fall on deaf ears. I really am not going to go back and forth on this.

Let’s start with actual numbers—YOUR OWN data.

If foreclosures were truly motivated, it wouldn’t take 5,000 mailers, calls, or texts to get a contract signed.

Your food analogy? You clearly don’t understand what a motivated seller is.

From your writing, it’s evident you believe a motivated seller is simply someone who wants to, needs to or has to sell their house (hence your foreclosure example).

The truth? A motivated seller is anyone willing to sell below market value, no matter what the reasons for selling are.

Let’s take your example—someone in foreclosure.

  • Don’t they HAVE to sell? Yes.
  • And if they don’t sell, aren’t bad things going to happen to them? Absolutely.
  • Are they willing to sell below market value? Absolutely not. At least 3,000 to 5,000 to 1 says NO!

These people would rather rip out the cabinets, take the fridge—hell, even burn the house down out of spite than sell at market value, let alone at a discount.

Let me simplify it for you:

5,000 mailers for one closed deal = 0.02% success rate.
That means your failure rate is 99.98%.

So, can you really sit there and tell me you can target motivated sellers when it takes 5,000+ attempts to close one deal? (Rhetorical question—the answer is obviously no.)

Numbers don’t lie.

Your opinion doesn’t change mathematics. The numbers are what they are.

If you could target motivated sellers (which is different from finding them), your failure rate wouldn’t be 99.98%, right? Right!

Now if you are a good sport, let's talk about your clever reference to the definition of motivated “according to dictionary” and let me show you where you went wrong:

First:

Motivation is an internal state that drives people to take some of action or make a decision. Yes. So in your/this case, this would translate to, “Yes, they decided they want to sell their house.. They agree to sell their house”. 

Sure, but you are missing the most important part. Coming to the decision to sell their house, is NOT the same as willingness to sell below market value. And there lies the grounds behind the fact that you can’t TARGET them. Remember, finding them, and targeting them are two completely different things.

Second:

Many people like you think that “circumstance” implies “motivation”. But that is wrong. Circumstance (like tax liens, foreclosure etc. etc.) does not in ANY way imply motivation. Motivation is an emotional response to a circumstance. Not the circumstance itself. So yes, although the sensible solution to a foreclosure is to sell fast for cash, the emotional response however is to find ways to keep their house not sell it.

I hope this makes you see the error in your ways.

I’ll repeat—I’m not here to debate this. Believe what you want. But this isn’t a contest of who’s right or wrong, who’s smart and who isn’t.

You can have that trophy—I truly don’t care.

My only intention was to correct a completely false narrative about lead generation, and instead, I’m met with pure and complete ignorance. But I won’t lose sleep over it.

Really, man… Keep sending mailers to the foreclosure list. I truly wish you the best of luck with that (not being sarcastic, I just truly don't care what you do with this knowledge... but I do hope you use it wisely). 

Your comment: "Numbers don’t lie."
My Stats prof taught me that there are lies, damn lies and statistics. ;-)


I fully agree Ken.
This guy gets on here and Spams discussions with false information.

Post: Agent looking to start direct to seller for motivated sellers

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Gregory Schwartz:
Quote from @Jerryll Noorden:

Try to change the way you think/approach success.

Said it before, will say it again.

A lot of people do this:

Hey… I have 3 wives, 4 girlfriends on the side, 5 dogs, 6 jobs, I can only devote $200 every 5 months, and I have only 2 hours/month available to work on my business… how do I become successful?

Instead, you need to realize that success (or the universe, for that matter) won’t bend backward for you.

Instead of asking how to become successful based on your limitations, you need to turn it around.

First, you need to determine what it takes to become successful!? Then, use what you have to get what it takes to become successful.

If success takes 12 hours a day, $3,000/month on marketing, a solid education, knowledge of marketing, and deal-making—then that is what it takes.

The reason most people struggle is exactly this.

Understand this.

You can’t target motivated sellers. It is absolutely impossible. The reason why? Because no one—and nothing—can predict when someone becomes motivated.

Circumstance (like foreclosure) does not imply motivation. Motivation is an emotional response to a circumstance, not the circumstance itself.

To fully grasp this, you need to understand what a motivated seller actually is.

Many people think a motivated seller is anyone who wants to, needs to, or HAS to sell their house.

That is wrong.

A motivated seller has only one characteristic:

Anyone willing to sell their house below market value. The reason why does not matter.

Take someone in foreclosure.

Do they have to sell? YES.

And if they don’t sell, aren’t they going to be in trouble? YES.

Are they willing to sell below market value? NO.

They’d rather burn the house to the ground out of pure spite than sell to you at market value—let alone at a discount.

Once you understand the basics, you’ll soon realize that the ways everyone tells you to get motivated seller leads are factually, universally wrong.

Not an opinion. Just pure facts.

You can’t target them. They target you.


Good ad for SEO but you didnt provide any tactical advice or answer my question. But thanks for spamming my post. 
He sells SEO if you can't tell.
Yes you can target motivated sellers and it works.

Post: Short Term Rental Issues with Property Management and General Consensus

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Cole Dobbs:
Quote from @John Underwood:

You already have all the tools and contacts in place to be successful at self managing. 

I would recommend you self manage and not pay out the 20% to 40% of your gross income. 


 Thank you John! I can see you have expertise on this subject! I am curious, how many rentals did you have before you turned to property management? Or do you have another method that you use and could recommend? Let me know!

-Cole


I mainly have a bunch LTR' with a couple STR's. I self manage all but one.

Post: Short Term Rental Issues with Property Management and General Consensus

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028

You already have all the tools and contacts in place to be successful at self managing. 

I would recommend you self manage and not pay out the 20% to 40% of your gross income. 

Post: Underwriting STR vacation rentals? Best software or excel template you can share?

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Selina Giarla:

I have been in long term rentals for about 15 years. I am looking into purchasing a STR/vacation property as another rental income business line to diversify and need to understand the underwriting. I am looking for suggestions on either underwriting software and/or excel templates for this type of underwriting. I don't know the average occupancy, ADR, etc. for this region so a software that is pretty good at predicting that would be helpful.

Also, for obtaining debt, do lenders price this as more risky? How are the loan terms typically written for this purchase and how have you fared in terms of the rate/length of loan, etc.?


 Software is only so good at predicting these things. You are better off manually looking at the potential competition on VRBO and Airbnb to get your best numbers.

STR spreadsheets have already been shared on here and you can search and find them.

Post: Montana possibly increasing property taxes on STR and second home owners

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028
Quote from @Adrian Clapp:

Montana’s proposed law would lower property taxes for primary residencesand long-term rental properties while increasing taxes on second homes and other high-value properties.

Pigeon Forge area made all STR's commercial properties and substantialy increased the property tax on these properties.

Unfortunatly this is the cost of doing business.


Post: STRs in residential areas: Another viewpoint

John Underwood
#5 All Forums Contributor
Posted
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
  • Posts 12,386
  • Votes 15,028

Another reason to focus on vacation rentals. Not the inner-city HOA property.

I buy places that I can take my family to on vacation and make memories.

I see people buying properties for a STR that only make 12k or less. I can buy a LTR for cash that I can make for than that per year with much less work.

I just bought a house at auction that I paid 32k for that will easily rent for $1500/month. I'll rehab it and have than $50k in it and rent it. Then I will only have taxes and insurance to pay each year. It will pay for itself in 3 years.

Best of all I'll never pay any tax on this income because my ROTH IRA owns the house.