Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Joel Florek

Joel Florek has started 35 posts and replied 521 times.

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Brandon Hicks:

@Joel Florek

I live in NE Indiana and have 63 units in smaller towns.

16 unit in Auburn which has a 13k population.

12 unit in Angola...8.6k pop college town

30 units (lots of smaller properties) in Kendallville 10k

Other 5 units are in smaller towns.

It’s been good. I self manage at this point. Never have an issue filling a vacancy. It’s all about bringing a good product to the marketplace in my opinion.

 We have to meet up at some point for a networking session. Sounds like I could do some good learning from you! What are your average rents and unit make up?

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Sara Martin:

@Joel Florek

Thank you so much for sharing this information. Sometimes the advice that these types of situations don’t work is coming from people who don’t even own property! The fear-mongers who instill negative situational happenings... thank you for the positive light - love what your doing. Would love to connect with you!

 We are all guilty at times of talking about things we dont have experience doing as if we are experts. Was hoping to hear stories from people investing in rural areas and it's turned into a great thread! Would love to connect and talk more.

Post: What takes priority in MF properties, strategy or market cycle?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Mike Hoherchak:

Thanks guys for the responses. I know there are things I don't know, so I'm just trying to shed a light on those things. 

@Joel Florek

@Joel Florek What do you mean by stretching the underwriting? I've never heard that phrase. I can assume what you mean by it, but was curious your definition.

 When people say that they can get 5% rental increases every year for the next 7 years. Or they assume that they can sell at a lower cap rate then what the current market is at. They assume that they can still refinance the property at the 5 year balloon with the current rates we see today. They pinch all of property management to 5% or

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Joel Florek:

My question is simple. Who is investing in rural America, why are you doing it and what is your experience? Is it your longterm goal or is it a temporary goal to achieve cash flow?

Lets define rural America as towns of less than 20k population without a major metro within 15 miles. 

I will start by saying that I am one of these investors. I have 23 units (a 3, 4, and 16 unit) in a rural town of 15k population. Overall, my experience has been fantastic from the perspective of stability, modest rent growth and long-term tenants. It amazed me how many people thought I was crazy for buying into the small town, but the cash flow and ability to find sellers who are willing to get creative on closing has offered the ability to scale with minimal funds available. 

I have also found that the lack of other options in many of these towns has positioned me to easily be viewed as one of the more or most professional management companies. Its common to only have a few available rental units on the market in the entire town for rent at a given time. 

My preference is to expand to larger markets, and I have added an 8 unit into a larger market which has also been a very positive experience.

My frustration has been getting more opportunities in larger markets that offer decent cash flow via purchasing around an 8cap. My ideal property is $1m to $2m right now. There seems to be a regular flow of opportunities in these smaller towns that I can get a 10cap or 12cap on, solid properties that I can depend on longterm, and provide me with cashflow. 

The biggest con is obviously the microeconomic risks are more acutely affected by changes in employment by one of the local major employers and the issue of lack of opportunity for appreciation since there arent tons of buyers on the market for these assets. 

Would love to get others feedback on their opinion of these smaller towns a long term or short term strategy. 

So, maybe look for towns not reliant on a single employer and/or an unstable industry. There are lots of towns like that to be found out there. Cool post. Made me remember how many different angles there are in this business. Yes, you might be the seller willing to offer creative terms to the next owner in the future - lol.

 I have actually thought a lot about that and have a short list of other investors who I like that I would be willing to offer a seller 2nd on to take over my portfolio should I need to make a change in my life quickly. Thinking through the exit strategy is a bit more important I think. 

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Kyle Kleiman:
@Joel Florek If you are absorbing some of the typical PM roles, what are you paying them? My first concern with this type of strategy was PM as well, but it sounds like you have it covered. I grew up 45 minutes away from Iron Mountain in Escanaba, so I find this whole thread especially interesting. How has your experience with contractors been up there? I figure there are probably quite a few in the area but some may not be quite as reliable. I sent you a PM request, would love to chat further!

 Great question. They pay $290 a month for rent in a unit where other long-term tenants pay $680. They mow the lawn at one of the 3 properties in the town, clean the common areas when needed, salt and snowblow the walkways during a storms. As mentioned they also answer maintenance calls for me, call contractors to get the issues resolved and do showings for me when I schedule them. They also drop of rent checks at the local bank for the tenants who dont use computers. I can view the checks online to record who paid, how much and when. They are retired and love having something to do. Since they never travel too far it works out really well. 

With respect to contractors, I have established the following: plumbing, HVAC, painting, lawns(for other properties), plowing, electrician(never needed), and I use Home Depot to deliver new appliances and take away old ones. For bigger projects, I still take those on myself. Eventually, I will hire them out but I will hand over my weekly property management duties before I let go of the capital improvement projects. I save a lot of money and hassle getting my hands dirty and do enjoy the work. Helps me understand what is going well or not well with the properties and plan for the future. Its my sweat equity. I have standard paint colors, flooring, and other things which makes the process easy for me. I picked up a small tool trailer and set it up to carry all my tools and leave room for supplies. Since I am mostly B class most of the time a tenant turn requires no cleaning or renovations unless I decide to update the unit and bump rents. Basically, emergency work gets hired out and I handle scheduled capital improvements. During winter I only need to do a few minor projects so I will only get my hands dirty for about 3 or 4 days from Dec through April. When we have warmer weather and see more turnover I usually spend 3 or 4 days a month getting my hands dirty. 

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Brian Ploszay:

@Joel Florek   Some of those smaller towns will not have new competition, meaning no new apartment stock is likely to be built.  For me, one of the downsides is logistics - I don't have time to drive more than 45 minutes to a property.

 Scale is important to build some systems around the business. For me, the 23 units I have are more than 400 miles away. I go up every other month to check on the portfolio, meet with my banker, and take care of some projects. Might spend 2 to 4 days working in the town. My parents lives about 75miles away so my wife, daughter and I stay with them. Ill drive to the properties and spend 8 to 10 hours working while my wife and daughter get to visit. Ends up being a great vacation for us and keeps us close to family. My resident manager opens doors for showings, meets contractors, does weekly drive bys of each property to ensure things look clean and as they should. I still manage all the leasing remotely, pay bills and record rent checks. 

Post: What takes priority in MF properties, strategy or market cycle?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741

@Mike Hoherchak in my opinion if you are buying a quality asset that cashflows and can provide moderate to strong returns you are in great shape. If you can lock in long-term fixed financing going after the small stuff, as long as you are ok hanging on if valuations turn around, you are ok. But if you are buying stuff just to buy and or really stretching the underwriting you can get yourself into a lot of trouble. The challenge is so many start to stretch the underwriting and it leaves fewer deals resulting in more people trying to stretch the underwriting to get a deal done. It is a vicious cycle until something forces a shock to the system. Stay patient and stay focused on the real goal with all this craziness and every day is always a good day to buy. 

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Jack Moran:

Great discussion topic.   

I just looked at a 3fam 3br each that's cash flowing like a mother but it's in a high density urban slum.  I would never be comfortable living there or seeing someone I care about live there.  Not a tree in sight, noplace for a kid to throw a ball, 3deckers on top of eachother, sunlight never reaches the ground, no offstreet parking.   Front Doors wide open swaying in the January wind.   Sad, depressing.   

The cash is real, but it made me sick to think I'd be getting rich on the misfortune of those without the wherewithall to get theselves out of it.  I was starting to think that a slum would be the natural progression of a focus on cash flow investing.  

You're example offers hope that cash flow investing doesn't need to be cheap high density urban decay.   Not only is there probably less competition in smaller towns, there's probably more room for a little dignity.  

Thanks!  

 There is some really terrible stuff out there. All my properties are square, have up to date plumbing and electrical and I would live in every unit that I rent. If I dont feel comfortable leaving a tool trailer over night I dont want to invest in the neighborhood or town. I have come across a lot of enticing opportunities from a numbers perspective, but this is about lifestyle so you have to say no to those properties. There are opportunities, just takes time and patience. I picked up my first two deals in 10 months. Then it took 18 months before I found another deal and the 4th got under contract only a few weeks after closing on the 3rd deal. Havent done a deal for 14 months now... Would love to get great deals all the time but would rather hang on and enjoy what I have and wait for the right play that I am comfortable with. 

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Ian Tudor:

@Joel Florek - is that an 10-12 cap with upside or stabilized?

 In the small town where I invest my 16 unit was purchased at a 9.5 cap 3 years ago. I added $1200 to the monthly rent roll via rental increases without renovations. Still another $800/mo that I can get out of it which I should be capturing by mid-fall next year. So the potential is to operate at a 12.3% cap. 

Smaller multifamily, 2 unit and 3 units can be picked up for 15 cap or 20 cap as is and even have some upside. I have only picked up one of these properties. But those usually come with their fair share of weird stuff which I don't like to deal with much. So I have passed on a lot of small opportunities(except that one I mentioned) just because the headaches dont seem to be worth it for me. I like to get the C+ tenants and then to B+ tenants. I haven't played with A and I stay away from low C to D stuff. 

Post: Rural Multifamily, who is doing it?

Joel FlorekPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Michigan City, IN
  • Posts 530
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Brian Ploszay:

I am not buying in these areas.  I noticed you were from Michigan City, Indiana, which is a place I know a bit.  I see momentum in the greater Northwest Indiana due to tax refugees from Chicago and/or Illinois.  

I think it is an interesting plan, if the smaller cities are relatively close to Michigan City.   So some of the towns in Western Michigan and the top half of Indiana.  The local economies of some of the small towns range from stable to declining.  Obviously avoid the declining areas.  Rarely are rural areas in the midwest a growth situation.  

Keep in mind it is harder to sell your properties in these towns.  The local buyer pool is limited.  Outside capital wants cheap and won't stretch because of the location.

Last idea - avoid lower income areas in rural towns.  Buy a property that has the potential of being stable, workforce housing.

 Thanks for the opposing view. All are valid and I cant argue against them. Longterm my plan is to get into the metros and I have started that with an 8 unit I picked up last year. I do sleep easier knowing I have assets in a stronger market long term. 

The draw to some of the smaller markets is I happened to start investing in one of these and it has been fantastic for me. Once you find something that works really well, its hard to turn a blind eye to focus on going in a different direction. Maybe its too small of a mindset and that limiting belief is holding me and others back.... All good food for thought. 

One of the things I think is interesting with small towns, especially in farming regions, and ones with tourists hooks is that they have a form of industry that is always going to provide a base. That protects from completely falling out. When you see vacancy rates at 0% or 2% its just crazy to me. Search in some of these little towns and you find 0 places for rent publicly advertised, but then you dig into it and there are a few hundred units in small multifamily properties. That is a strong position to be in as an owner. Then again so many large cities see strong occupancy rates as well with the only threat being the rapid development of new complexes.