Perhaps some details would bring this situation into sharper focus and why my "spidey senses" are tingling.
This is a peculiar property to say the least. It is about one acre of land that has two homes on it. The two homes share a single well/septic system.
Home 1
This is the older of the two. It is about 1,000 sqft. and is a 2/1. House is about 80 years old, has an old stone basement and oil heat. The upside is it has been completely rehabbed inside already. The downside is the oil heating system which I'm unfamiliar with. House would probably rent for about $550/Mo.
Home 2
This home is about 1,600 sqft 3/2. It is newer than house 1. It has a newer boiler style heating system, no central a/c. This house has also been completely rehabbed inside. It has Pella windows, travertine tile all over the place, a completely pine plank lined den. Also here is the kicker with this property. There is an approximately 1800 sqft. garage/gymnasium attached to it. Seriously I've never seen anything like it. You could park like a half dozen cars in this thing, or two large motor homes or have a full size basket ball court. This house would rent for probaby around $900ish.
The asking price for the whole property? $59K
Now this same property sold six years ago for $198K. This is a bank owned deal so it could be that they are just dumping it, but it really hasn't been on the market that long (about 2 months).