Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Jim Costa

Jim Costa has started 1 posts and replied 86 times.

Post: buying with an undermarket tenant in place - advice sought

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

I like the title of this post.  Shashy has lots of information and options.  Unfortunately part of the offer is she can't just raise the rents.

Rather than repost the same question what about those that can change rents.  I am in the process of buying 3 duplexes that is undervalued because of rents.  They are renting for $800-850.  Market rents for this size in this neighborhood. should be 1100-1200.  Once you purchase how do you raise rents that high.  It is a business decision to buy but how do you go in to somebody that has been living there for  several years and pays rent on time and say you are going to raise rents 50%.   We are not in rent control.  I can do what I did before but this will take me 3-4 years to get rents to todays market rents.   This is costing 20K a year in lost potential rents.  Where is the line between a money hungry investor and a landlord with a heart.

Post: buying with an undermarket tenant in place - advice sought

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

@Roy N.

I understand that they will not use cap rate for small units but they will certainly use the income to qualify.   The fact still remains that discounted $300 a month versus $900 fair market rents will affect the amount that she can borrow thus "making it more difficult to get a loan"  Once she has just a few properties and needs to use the income from the properties to qualify for the loan it will make a huge impact.  They use 60% of rental income to offset debt.  That $600 difference at 60% is $360 (to be applied to a payment).  That can result in another $70,000 of borrowing power.  We don't know the numbers but percentage of the purchase price is huge.   Many investors would have a hard time coming up with an additional 70K down payment just to make the numbers work. (I'm sure the numbers are a little higher in New Jersey)

The lack of income will affect what you can buy in the future.  You can adjust for that in terms of what you pay now.  It sounds like Shashy did that. 

Interested to see how it works out.

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

The HELOC or 2nd won't be an issue until you hit 5 properties. You will want to refinance your seconds into your first before you get your 5th mortgage. Read my post in the forum"

"15 year vs 30 year on 96K rental income"

Page 2, I talk about mortgages.  This is a great thread as well about buying your next property.  Similar situation.  She is buying first property and not sure if she should go 30 year cheaper or 15 year to pay off sooner.

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

$730 not making since unless you are including Taxes and insurance. It looks you are buying 120K @ 5 % down equals 6K. You are scaring me at the refi in 6 months. This is horrible to pay all the fees again. Rates are at an all time low. Get the 30 year fixed. Don't mess with it. This is your first home. Check with their guidelines for 6 months. I always understood that it was a year. At one year you can get an appraisal. $3-500 instead of $3-5000 refi. They will take the appraisal and if the LTV is less than 80% they should drop the PMI off your payment. Also at one year I would recommend getting a HELOC (Home Equity Line Of Credit). This is just a line of credit. If you don't use, it doesn't cost you anything. They might charge an annual fee of $50-250. Sometimes they wave if you have a balance. A HELOC can go up to 100% for owner occupied.

This will get you into the house for as little as possible, payment as little as possible and money in a year as cheap as possible.  Just be sure if you take the money out that you put it into another property.

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

what happen to the 3-3.5?  by the time my post went through you posted more

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

This must be owner occupied.    That is a smoking rate.  I am sure some of your fees are going towards buying down the rate.  Wells Fargo is aggressive.  They are the top mortgage provider out their.  They do almost 1 out of every 4 loans.  Fees still seem high.  Sometimes the preapproval rates are different then the final rates.  Run the numbers.  Be sure it is 30 year fixed.  Ask what the fees will be at  4%.  See if the savings justifies the monthly savings.  What is your end game.  Are you going to sell in a few years or plan on keeping in portfolio forever.

Post: 15 year vs 30 year on 96K rental income

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

Yes.  I own 10 properties 2 are free and clear.  It is nice to collect the money and not have a mortgage.  I also find myself not in a hurry to get things done as quick because they are paid off. Bad habit to get into.  I'm thinking of refi now ( I have to do within 6 months) while rates are low and buying more units.

For advanced investors and those wanting to buy more than 4 units here is my take on mortgages:

I have always been on top of mortgages and underwriting guidelines which unfortunately gives me more knowledge than most mortgage brokers.  It is hard to find a good mortgage broker that knows what he/she is doing.  This isn't to bash on the profession but most are geared for your basic owner occupy purchase black and white loan.  When you get into the investors arena competent brokers that are willing to do the work are hard to find but they are worth their weight in gold when you find one.  Specially starting out.  The guidelines have changed drastically over the last 10 years.  I am not an expert but this is what I have figured out from hours of research and asking questions from my mortgage brokers.  Most of this information can be found on a google search for Fannie Mae investor guidelines, cash out, or 5-10 units.

Their are 2 main ways a bank can do a loan.  They can prepare a loan for a portfolio loan (more on this later) or they can prepare a loan that meets Fannie Mae guidelines.  Most banks when the loan is complete and they have collected all their fees they sell the loan on the secondary market.  This was the problem with the real estate bubble, bad loans were sold but that is another subject.

Most banks use Fannie Mae guide lines because once they sell the loan they get more cash in to do another loan and charge more fees.  Thy are "flippers".  They find the property (borrower),  Do all the repairs (underwrite the loan) and sell on the secondary market. Step and repeat.

Fannie Mae guidelines changed as of 2009

1-4 mortgages

Fannie Mae guidelines are the same for the most part on 1-4 properties of 1-4 units. This is where most investors will fall and where most banks are comfortable lending. Once you have an investment property you now have to provide leases and the loan becomes a little more difficult. You have vacancy factors, capex, management fees, FMR, FMV, appraisals, front end ratios, back end ratios. Many times you will need letters to be written to explain things. Many brokers don't want to do the work. You will see a separation here from brokers looking for the automated acceptance to the professionals that step up and do what it takes. An investor in this category is similar to buying their first rental. Same hoops. You can get a first, put together a heloc for repairs and to buy more property. You can refinance and take cash out for new purchase.

5-10 mortgages

Now it gets a lot more interesting. Many banks don't even want to tread in these waters. The Fannie Mae guidelines become a lot more stricter. The LTV goes to 25% for SFR and 30% for 1-4 unit. So you will need a larger down payment. They want 6 months of PITI payments in reserve liquid funds for all your properties. All of the paper work above but now for 5-10 properties. If you have 4 plexes now you are talking about getting 20-35 leases and documenting everything. This loan now becomes a lot of work requiring many hours to put together. A good broker will be willing to do it. Once you hit 5 properties you can no longer get cash out (delayed financing exception). This also means for your existing properties. It may take you several years to get to this position. You may have seconds on some of your properties. you may have bought a property 15 years ago for 100K you have a mortgage for 80K. 5 Years later you get a 50k Home equity line of credit (HELOC). To continue buying property and to fix things up, another 5 years go buy and you are now ready to buy your 5th house (mortgage). You think when this is done I would like to combine the first and 2nd of my old investment property and get a new first and take advantage of the low interest rates. Maybe you even paid the first down to 60K. So you are looking at a new first of only 110K on a property worth 175K. Because you will be in the 5-10 mortgages and refinance for a second is considered cash out you will not qualify or be able to pull cash out. For those cash buyers. Fannie Mae changed the rules in 2009 because of the number of foreclosures that were taking place and to try and encourage investors to buy inventory from the auctions. If you fall into the 5-10 category and are fortunate enough to buy a property all cash at close. Fannie Mae will let you take advantage of "delayed" financing. In a nutshell they will let you refinance and pull out 65% LTV.

Over 10 mortgages not available for Fannie Mae guidelines seek alternative funding or find a bank that does portfolio lending.

A lot of smaller banks under 10 branches  or credit unions are focused on their clients and offer what is called portfolio loans.  All this means is that they are not planning to sell on the secondary market so they don't have to meet Fannie Mae guidelines.  When the loan is done they plan on keeping the loan as part of their portfolio and will continue to collect the payments.  This is great for you because it is back to old school banking.  Lets loan to the people of character and look at the over all package.  Don't get me wrong the numbers still have to make since but they make up their own guidelines.  They can play with the ratios.  The downside to this is sometimes they don't want to tie up their money.  You may have a hard time getting a 30 year fixed rate mortgage.  Most of these loans are looked at as a commercial loan.  You may get a 30 year amortization but maybe a 10 year balloon.  Because these are portfolio loans, they make up the rules.  I would encourage once you are comfortable with real estate investing and you want to continue to invest you start looking for banks that offer portfolio loans and start to build a relationship with them.  

For those that took the time to read this, you now more than most brokers and most bankers. 

 Next time you walk into your bank ask your banker can I ask you a question. 

"Do you guys do real estate portfolio loans?" If you don't get that deer in the headlight look he/she will quickly guide you to the manager or to someone that does "loans" because that is all they understood. Once you get to a "mortgage specialist", you can ask if they do portfolio loans or if everything they do has to meet Fannie Mae guidelines. They will probably say they use Fannie Mae guidelines. Your next question is " if I own 5 properties can I refinance to take cash out as long as my LTV is under 70%" If they say yes, move on because they don't know the rules. If they are humble and say I'm not sure let me check into it, then they might be willing to do the work to get it to go through. If they say not if you own 5-10 properties. Fannie Mae won't allow cash out refinance. They know their stuff and that is the broker you want to work with. Good luck in your future portfolio building.

Buy Right!

Post: 15 year vs 30 year on 96K rental income

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

Congrats! Asma

Remember your goal.  You need to plan your work, then work your plan.  The $175 extra cash flow needs to go to work for you.  If you just spend it which is nice and fun,  You will still have a big mortgage in 15 years and nothing to show for it but maybe some shiny things you purchased and no longer have value.  To save up a 20% down payment  will take you another 9 years.  

Get creative try and buy the same thing you just did. Use the $175 cash flow to pay for the down payment loan. HELOC, personal loan, hard money, seller finance down. Lots of options.

Buy Right!

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

I just got 158K loan and it is quoted at 10K cost.  A couple things.  2K is prepaid items.  This is for your taxes and insurance which you have to pay anyway.  New loan requirements, if it is not listed in quote they can't charge you.  A lot of brokers are over estimating to cover themselves.  Go through line items and ask what could be lower.  I bought down the rate because I plan keeping in my portfolio long term.  I had to pay premium for non owner and over 5 properties.  Appraisals can range from 300-1000.  Know the numbers so you can figure for future.  

Post: Take the equity? Hold? Sell?

Jim Costa
Posted
  • Investor
  • Washougal, WA
  • Posts 86
  • Votes 52

If you are going hard money, do the bank loan first. Hard money doesn't care as much about your other property. They are looking at the deal you present them. The numbers have to make since to them. If you don't pay they take the property that is 60-70% ARV. They will wholesale it out to get their money back and move on to the next one. With the small numbers a private local funder or partner would be best. They put up the cash you do the work and labor and split the profit. Post scenario on BP or Craigslist and see who responds. If you get response go to next step. If not then move on.