Quote from @John McKee:
TD will work with you, but you have to keep bugging underwriting. Sometimes you have to pay a higher rate or adjust your expectation of how much you can pull out of the property.
Other's that I have heard of doing a Heloc are 5th 3rd, Penn fed, hurst lending.
Today I'll try the forth follow up with TD to get their opinion of replacement value for the insurance. They say the insurance agent's value is too low.
Fifth third declined, for among other reasons, that the rent isn't a "stable monthly acceptable income source." That's for a heloc on the primary residence. They wouldn't allow an application for the second home or the rental home.
TD declined an application for the second home because the the trust ownership became irrevocable upon the death of the settlor. Who knew that revocable versus irrevocable was a deal breaker?
I'm amazed that a 10% loan to value, first position, heloc, is so difficult.