@Charles Kao That info was easy to find. Hurricane Ivan hit there in 2004, and that changed things apparently.
@Parker Cox Thank you. I spoke with a second insurance agent in that area this afternoon who also said it wasn't possible for him to get me an accurate quote without the elevation certificate/survey. He said that home was in a 9ft flood zone and that nothing below 9 feet would be covered in the event of flooding. He thought flood insurance may be in the neighborhood of $5,000 - $7,000 per year (ouch!). He didn't mention a $10 fee to quote though ;)
@John Thedford Thanks, I did check. It was also recommended that I contact the mortgage holder to ask what they are paying for insurance.
@Bryan Wallace Wonderful! Thank you! I'll give them a call in the morning. The auction starts on Friday, so probably not enough time to get an EC (we just found the house today).
The neighbor (down the street) is paying $3,200 per year.