@Ali Boone Great options and points of clarity you mention.
Naga, I'm leaning toward BRRRR over turnkey because of the greater profit potential, and because I finished the book on BRRRR (and want to apply it, and know someone who is doing it who can help guide me.
Leaning toward local because this is my first real deep dive into REI apart from my primary residence, and I want it to be close by so I can learn hands on. Also, my mentorship can be hands-on and close by as well, which I prefer. (Not to mention, Indianapolis is a nice market.)
Additionally, I'm considering househacking at the same time with the house I already live in, since I JUST got a vacant room. Perhaps using it as an AirBnb rental is at the the top of my list.
Using the BiggerPockets Intention Journal is helping me get out of analysis paralysis.
Next step is securing financing options and making offers from analyzed deals that already have great numbers.
Getting in the game!