@David Ducille.
Thanks for the reply....realy appreciate it. I should have explained the properties better than just saying they are not "crap". They are not fixer uppers. We will be buying the homes for 20 to 25% less than there current appraised values.....not of our estimated value of them. 2 of them have actually been completed remodeled 5 years ago or so. The other 3 are very presentable homes as rentals that would need paint, some replaced floor coverings, clean up the outside, HVAC tune-up, etc if current tenants decided not to stay.
The key thing that attracts us to these homes is the same thing that attracted us to our current rentals......quality homes in quality neighborhoods. We definitely take a different approach than the average investor/landlord as we take tremendous pride in providing a nice home for our tenants to live and treat them with the upmost respect. (provide lawn treatments for weeds, fix issues within 24 hours most of time, provide furnace filters, etc). In return, in the years we have been doing this, we get very few calls and our monthly cashflow is truly passive income....We have never not returned a full deposit because our tenants have taken great care of our properties and it would have just been flat out wrong to keep it.
I definitely respect the comment about not being in real estate investing to make $200 a house.....but the vast majority of the time, its $200 per month for doing nothing.....and obviously it will be a lot more when the homes are mortgage free. Our main goal in real estate has always been to provide a nice retirement through passive income. (I totally get the BRRRR method and DEFINITELY a better way to make more money....and I am certainly not opposed to it.....but wanting to have rentals in neighborhoods we would live in ourselves makes the BRRRR very challenging in the current housing market).
With the new purchases, we would hopefully just raise the rent as the leases expire to increase monthly cashflow and the current tenants would stay. However, if some tenants did decide to leave, we would certainly put the elbow grease in and make any upgrades to make them homes tenants will be proud to live in.
I like your idea of possibly flipping one and keeping 4.....that makes alot of sense financially.