Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Jon Graham

Jon Graham has started 12 posts and replied 64 times.

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Ed S.:

Great thread to read!

I love this site to gain onsite and knowledge.

Maybe it was in your comments, if you have debt you have a carrying costs, along with R/E taxes, insurance.

I'm a cash guy.

Option one: 3% down FHA
Option two: 100 % down cash

Great problem to have.

Short sale sucks!

I do have a mortgage. Taxes and everything is about 850 a month so that would def be a consideration. I had enough good intrest it hopefully doesn't factor in on this one. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

In this business you have two options, fast and quick, take what is offered or negotiate the absolute highest price in a hot market. Fast and quick is for those risk adverse having no negotiating skills. The rest of us work every deal to realise the bigger returns. No offer is final except mine.

The advantage in selling a personal home is you are dealing with a emotional decision on the part of a buyer. Emotions are something which can easily be taken advantage of and manipulated. When you know they want the place you take advantage of their weakness. It means some risk and some work but that is what makes it fun.

What are you talking about LOL. You obviously still didn't even read my original question anyway...

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Eric Munson:

@Jon Graham Wow I'm surprised at some of the comments here. Have you all dealt with banks and borrowers before? Take the cash offer and close it. It's worth $2k to not go through the BS of an FHA borrower.

I am pretty suprised too by people not suggesting just take the cash since the offers are so close. I kind of anticipated more of a discussion on how far the spread of profit would be before a cash offer wouldn't be as enticing. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30

This listing has gone absolutely crazy. When we listed the house we listed almost 15k more than any house has sold in our market in the last 6 months. We know we are at the top of what we can get and get appraised for and I don't think we undershot the listing prince. The showing realtors are all contacting my agent and asking about offers ahead of time. My agent also sent out a multiple offer notice to the people who have offered. 

I've had 5 showings so far and 3 offers. I have 11 more showings scheduled today and tomorrow! So exciting. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @David Faulkner:

Good suggestions all ... it all comes down to how likely you think each are to close and adjusting according to that, which is always easier said than done. Once you've made the mental risk adjustments, then yes you can certainly counter any offers on price or terms. Any additional due diligence you and/or your agent could do to qualify the buyers may help ... what is(are) the source(s) of funds? Do you know and have you talked with the prequal lenders? Do their buyer's agent seem competent? Some additional research may help, but there will always be some educated guesswork and you'll need to recognize when you've hit the point of diminishing returns. Do you personally prefer a bird in the hand or go for two in the bush? I unfortunately learned this the hard way when I sold my rental, and had to sell it something like 7 times because none of the FHA buyers could close, but this was way lower end than your property (which looks great btw), so your mileage may vary. Good luck!

The cash buyer sent his bank statement with the offer so he's the most qualified LOL. He's got the cash to buy. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

@Jon Graham   Some do, some don't.  I do have experience with people trying to make me lose other potential buyers and then cutting the price.

I never put up with that. 

 I'm in a position of power here to since I'm currently living in the house and not in a rush to sell. I like the way you think LOL. I have been in situations in the past where I was in desperate need of a sale and it was infuriating negotiating inspection repairs. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
Originally posted by @Jon Graham:
Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

I'd take the cash offer. 

What if the spread was more? Is there a rule of thumb on the ratio of lower cash offer vs higher financed offer? 

 It kind of depends on how much you are gonna net, what your income and other resources are. $5k I'd take the highest offer, but $3k or less I'd probably take the sure thing.

It depends too on what I can get the home to appraise for. Ive been doing this long enough that I know what the house will appraise for and whether it's going to be hard to get a certain price past an appraiser.

Appraisers in our market have been flexible lately trying to allow the market grow, but even still we are close to the top of what I think we will get. So that is def a consideration here as well. 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

@Jon Graham   I would go with the cash offer unless they want to take longer than the financed options.  I would also make sure they knew going in, there would be ZERO price reductions based on inspections.

I did have that thought to about inspection repairs. Do you have experience with cash buyers requesting more repairs at inspections? Not that I'm anticipating any. This house is perfect :) But I have had ridiculous repair requests on other properties in the past.  

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:

I'd take the cash offer. 

What if the spread was more? Is there a rule of thumb on the ratio of lower cash offer vs higher financed offer? 

Post: Multiple offers - Which one is best?!

Jon GrahamPosted
  • Property Manager
  • St. John, IN
  • Posts 67
  • Votes 30
Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

Since you are in a strong market I would go back to number one with a counter. Accept his offer with him paying all closing costs. If he refuses go to # 2 with the same offer then #3.

Thanks for the feedback Greg. As I mentioned above I'm trying to get opinions on how to evaluate my current offers, without getting into strategies on how to negotiate the highest purchase price. My real question is if a slightly lower cash offer is better than a higher FHA loan offer. And what is the breaking point. Besides that there are deadlines to all three offers so if I start countering individually I will miss out on the opportunity of countering the others.