Dion -- thanks for the response. A couple clarifications:
As I mentioned in my above post, the verbal offer contained a 3-year balloon but I am not considering the balloon in the numbers here. If that deal goes through, then I might just hold the note for 3 years. I am more interested in the concept of if a note buyer would even consider buying a note like this as if it was in 1st position if, in the sales agreement, it is stated that the proceeds of the sale of the note would go first to paying off entirely the original 1st lien.
The potential buyer that made the verbal offer is not a desperate borrower in my initial conversations with him. He is a local investor who owns multiple rentals in the area and would like to purchase the property to hold as a rental. I haven't dug deep into his borrowing history nor will I until I decide this is the route I'd like to take (which I'm still not sure of).
As for the "obvious question": "Why are you not selling the property in the open market for $73k or even $65k"? That is a very relevant question. There are a few different reasons:
1) I've attempted to sell the property straight up and while there has been some interest from buyers in purchasing the property, all of them have so far been unable to obtain a loan.
2) I imagine that offering owner financing would open the doors to many more potential buyers.
3) I'd like to get some experience with notes. I can be a little patient in terms of getting my money out of this property and I thought that this could potentially help in getting my foot in the door of the note world. I'm willing to take a larger discount for the experience and knowledge.
As for the property value, it's Zestimate is $90k+. I can hear your eyes rolling. =)
The ONLY reason I point out the Zestimate is to show how crazy this particular area is. I don't believe the property is worth $90k but I do believe it is worth every bit of $70k retail. This particular area is good or bad block-by-block. This one happens to be an excellent block. A smaller house (though rehabbed) sold for $110k+ just 6 houses north of this one. Mine does not need anything other than cosmetic updates and is larger. I believe the massive value swings block by block have also hindered my attempts at selling it straight up.
Regarding the balance of the 1st lien, I'd rather not openly discuss that until this property is sold. I can say that I'd like to receive $50k in order to pay off the loan and have some capital for another project. I am anticipating getting at least $10k more out of it after all is said and done.