Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Christian Hutchinson

Christian Hutchinson has started 45 posts and replied 346 times.

Post: Newbie from Southfield, Michigan

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Shaun Drone:

@Lynn Lewis I have made 2 connections with individuals who have a total of 7 homes between them in the area. One gentleman owns two with his wife and combined with outside investors to buy two more. The second gent owns one and bought another he is renting to his cousin. 

I have learned about time to profit, researching rental prices, and the value of seeing a property first hand. This last detail is key in his area as often homes look good in pictures, but are in the block with 6 abandoned homes. I'm not looking for that type of investment. 

 HI Shaun,

Welcome to the The Game.

You are looking for your first property? I don't know what type of cash and credit you have.  But I'm three years deep in this.  So I'm just past training wheels.

I highly suggest anyone doing this the first time if you are not flush with cash.  Go Duplex in a working class/middle class city.  So your side of town, Westland, Garden City would be solid. If you have some extra cash and can stand higher monthly expenses Ferndale is good too, if you are coming back east.

Or you could go Middle Class/Upper Middle Class Area, condo with low fees. Canton, North Farmington, Commerce, even Novi might have a deal you can score.

Try to avoid anything requiring a lot of work on your first time around.  Paint, carpet, etc is cheap, and labor is easy to come by.  But electrical, plumbing, and other "guts" related stuff on your first go around I would shy away from. You want to close the property and have a paying tenant in less than 30 days.  You have 60 days until the first mortgage payment so, those first two months rent help you with cash reserves, and offsetting renovation cost.

After you do one or two properties, then try stuff more risky.  The amount you learn on your first 1-3 rentals is insane.

Good Luck!

Roof and Plumbing...

I don't have the cash or the reserves to bring the house down to studs and really correct the problem with plumbing. Its a ticking time bomb.

Roof issues, its one thing to have to do a small repair.  But replacing a roof, I rather pass. 

Post: Completely starting over (divorce)

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Scott K.:

Well damn.  Its been a week since I was told the great news that she is moving on.  Didn't see it coming.

So here is where I stand.  we own 3 total properties 2 are free and clear and the one that we still owe on (103k) is where we let my nephew live with his son.

So she will stay in the property that we live in now.  I am getting the Roseville property that is rented out for 800.  She wants to refinance the 103k property to get the payment lowered.  So she would take ownership of that property.  Not sure how I feel about that since it is the house of my parents and I grew up there.

So best case is I have a free and clear property in Roseville Michigan just about 6 miles north of Detroit that the value should be about 70k.  Should also have about 30k cash in the bank.  And a paid off car.  My biggest problem s I don't have a real job for getting future financing will take a while.  I don't plan on stopping with rentals just trying to figure out how to recover from this.  This was not in the plan of the way I had it planned out.

Its been a week since the news and I am trying to figure out to keep the Roseville property rented out for 800.  Maybe I could pick up a cheap property and fix it up as I live there.  Is it possible to get a loan on the Roseville property of 70% and use that to get into another property?

I have not slept very well lately and I just need to make good sound decisions.  So if anyone that has been through this could suggest a few things would be great.

wow thats the first time I have put those words so I could read them.  Life will go on 

 Thats a tough break, I would suggest owner-occupied duplex.  Some solid choices under $120K between 8-16 Mile off Woodward.  We are poking around trying to find something now.

Post: Newbie from Plymouth, Michigan

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354

Welcome to real estate...

My Wife and I have been at this for 3 years.  I don't know how much money/credit you have.  But I tell anyone who is getting started. Your first try should be a condo with low fees, or a duplex in an area you know well.

So many things to learn, keep it simple and low risk to start. Being in Plymouth, there is a couple of great markets to start off in Ypsilanti, AA, Westland, and Canton.

Good luck

Post: Profit, Ethics & Capitalism

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354

"Greed is Good"

If you don't understand that, its very difficult to make money.

Originally posted by @Christian Carson:
Originally posted by @Derrick Neal:

Metro Detroit might be the most stable market in the US. Price are low,banks don't write out mortgages, that translate into rentals. Yeah u might buy home here for 10k or 20k whatever it might be.It might never appreciate to nothing... but it will always rent for no less then 700per month..

 Are you saying that you have lines of _QUALIFIED_ tenants for these houses? In those types of areas with that rental price point, probably 90% of my applicants fail my screening process. Sometimes we go for a few months without seeing a good applicant. When you're below $700/mo, you're scraping the bottom of the barrel. Think about the type of person who is looking for a place at that price point. Basically, I need someone who is making $12/hr. Many of these folks do not have stellar rent/credit/crime histories. At that point, lowering the rent by $100 is not going to attract a better tenant.

 The $600/month market is a tough market...I have two places in that realm...SO far this is what we always do.  Washer/Dryer in the unit, I still charge a higher security deposit, and I still require 3 times the monthly rent.  Essentially if the Washer and Dryer magically disappear I have enough deposit to get a new one.  So far it has never been an issue.  I get people who might have been looking at $800 to come down to $600 because they get a Washer/Dryer and a yard versus an apartment in a nicer area. Of course my $600 unit gets some special applicants who I don't get on my $900 units.

Post: Selling a Rental

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Jeff McCaskey:

you don't want to do an owner carry??

How do you know that your current tenant can get a loan? Are they pre-approved already??

If you want to sell to them they would have to at least be able to show you they are pre-approved with a bank. 

 How do you Owner carry?
I imagine they can't get pre-approved.  They have unreportable income. I made their parents(doctors) co-sign their lease.  So I'm really thinking this is ultimately a deal with their parents.  Basically, do their families want to cut their kids housing expenses in half?

Biggest obstacle, is the tenants are not married, they are about 24, so I could see them being shy about a long-term investment.

Post: Selling a Rental

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354

I have a rental...It was originally occupied by myself and wife.  We moved 2 1/2 years ago, and turned it into a rental.  We notified the tenant, we would not be renewing the lease(expires August 31) and will sell the property in Q4 this year.  The tenant doesn't want us to sell.  Whats some ways to sell them the house?  I want this done easy.

I am willing to give up putting it on the market and gaining money on the sale, because I get to cut out the Realtor...Comps are $85K in our area, and but I am willing to sell for $75K, if this can be done quick and easy, with minimal cost out of pocket, for either party. FYI, the tenant would save $400 per month if they took our offer of $75K based on what they are paying for rent, they pay $900, and they cover their own utilities except water.  The water Bill is $45/month.

We bought the home as a short sale in Nov 2009, so we make pretty good money either way.

Suggestions?

Post: Purchase of owner occupied duplex advice

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354
Originally posted by @Jordyn Matusevich:

Thank you everyone for their advice! I do not want to do an FHA loan because the PMI never goes away. Is it true that if you purchase a duplex you must put 15% down?

It seems like most of you do not think this is the best idea. Before this opportunity came about we were planning on buying a house and moving out of this rental anyway and our ceiling was 300k but thought we could stretch it a bit for a good deal/to stay where we are with the upgrade of moving to the other, bigger nicer unit/and have the supplemental income for not so much work. Wishful thinking?

There is a possibility we could get the house for less - it just went on the market. Perhaps if it doesn't sell for a bit we'd have some wiggle room. 

I used a different mortgage calculator that includes tax, PMI, etc and got the following numbers - a higher monthly payment.

Thanks all!

Loan Information

Price of property:$319,000
Down payment (5%):$15,950
Loan amount:$303,050
Interest rate:4.500%
Loan term:30 Years
Payoff date:Feb, 2045
You have 360 payments that total to:$724,468

Monthly Payment Information

Principal and interest payment:$1,535.51
Property Taxes:$265.83
Hazard insurance:$79.75
Private Mortgage Insurance:$131.32
Total monthly payments:$2,012.41

 I would do this deal.

Your Initial investment is $16,000.

Your yearly payment is $24,149

One unit gives you $15,600

Once your PMI Falls off, you get a new home, and add the second unit. The PMI will probably be equal to the increase in Property Taxes because its no longer the primary residence. Which gives you $31200 a year in revenue, and about $7000/yr in income before repairs.

I measure my deals in Cash Out Flows. Remember you can get 7% return by putting $10,000 in an Index Fund, and just keep breathing. You are considering this transaction because you want a higher ROI. Well you will have a healthy return on your initial cash investment, plus all you need is 19 Rent payments per year to break even.

We would do a deal like this, as long as there was no: structural issues, major repairs coming due, or evidence the area was in was headed towards a downturn(major employer leaving, falling rents/property values).

Post: Flip rehab vs rental rehab

Christian HutchinsonPosted
  • Investor
  • Detroit, MI
  • Posts 360
  • Votes 354

So far we have have position ourselves for several rental flips...Our first set are coming due to sell in 6-18 months.

We put 8-15K into a rehab, we knew going into it the money needed to flip it was not there.  So now the comps are there.

I've read and heard to flip a house its $10K profit every 60 days you are holding.

We decided to rehab, rent, then sell.  Because it appears we will get about $30K on the sale after holding 2-3 years.  In the mean time we have cleared about $900 a month on the property. So we will make $$33K in rental income, plus another $30K on the sale in three years.  Of course there is a real risk in holding property for that long. But we try to inspect for major repairs, and we are properly insured.