I think the Homewood houses you mentioned could experience a market correction in lower home values as, like you mentioned, a small house in Edgewood will be priced pretty high. However, the location, schools and charm of Edgewood (and the Hollywood area) to me makes it a fairly safe bet. Lot values are high...many livable houses are being demolished so that a new, $700,000 list houses can be built. Buyers like the charm but many want a new/newer house also, that is driving that trend in in Homewood. Most of the new houses luckily are being built to blend in with the character of the neighborhood. An older house may appreciate well in this area if it is structurally sound as new higher priced houses are being built that may go for 700,000 while you can find a much more affordable house that may have been built in the '30s for 250,000- 300,000, although the newer houses generally are larger. West Homewood, west of I-65, has more affordable properties and I think will hold value because of their central location and schools, you give up some of the character that Edgewood has, but I don't see that as a problem. South side can be good for rentals or flips, it is too well located in my opinion to take a big drop. Hoover is good, esp those zoned for Hoover high school. Mtn Brook is tricky, houses are generally too expensive to get a good rent return on, but the poss of building or flipping is there if you can find a deal in that area, which is hard to come by. Vestavia I think is a good investment. Houses were built in the '50s-60s I think, and small dens and unused dining rooms keep prices lower, but they can be remodeled or bulldoze and build if you get a deal. Or you can turn that dining room into a bed and bath and make a 3/2 into a 4/3.