Quote from @Joshua Stein:
I'm one year into having a property manager take over one of our properties, it's mainly great because that income is now (almost) truly passive - probably requires less than 1 hr of time each month.
However, my PM seems to have had a bit of trouble scaling. I'll ask for them to do something (HVAC tune-up, turn off exterior water before winter, etc) and, while they'll initially acknowledge the email, I usually have to follow up multiple times to confirm the task is completed.
Is this a pattern with most PMs? What are your general expectations of a PM and when/how do you generally know it's time to look for a new one?
I'm trying to gauge if I'm being too type A and need to let go a bit, or if I'm underestimating what a PM should do.
What you've described sounds like probably most client/PMC relationships. What you're describing sounds to me like a problem with systems and probably not people. Usually, the people at the PMC want to do a decent enough job, but if the right systems are not in place, they cannot consistently deliver.
Also, it's important - as others have said - for you to understand the dynamics at play. Let me use one of your examples to explain what I mean:
HVAC Tune Up: Now this is something the tenant did not request, so the tenant probably doesn't care that it gets done. This means that the PM can create a WO and send it to the HVAC company, but then the PMC has two options: 1) Trust the HVAC vendor will schedule with the tenant and get this done and send the invoice or 2) Set a reminder to follow up on this every day until it's done.
Now, if you're in PM, you can see that #2 above probably costs money and has a low ROI. The only party pushing to get this item done is you, and there is just not pressure from any other side for the PMC to continue to follow up with this. The way I see it, the PM in this situation is really relying on what is probably a 3rd party vendor, to be organized and get it done. I know we have a really good HVAC vendor who is extremely organized (part of why we like them) but in reality, this is more the exception than the rule. So if the PMC is expected to do #2 in my example above, how many other situations like your HVAC tune up are they setting reminders to follow up on? This could be an entire 40 hour/week payroll position if this is what they are doing.
Turning off the exterior water before winter (maybe this means disconnecting hoses?): This is one where the PMC absolutely should have a reminder set and ensure it happens.
At my company, we do have a task called "following up with open work orders to ensure completion" - but the truth of the matter is, that this is lower on the daily priority list than many many other tasks. It has to be. We strive to be the best company in the world, but the nature of PM is that we deal with thousands of micro-transactions every single day, and we have to determine triage on those items, even with great systems and checklists.
TL;DR: I think you should set communication expectations with your PMC and make sure you guys are on the same page!