@Rico See
In case you haven't spent enough time on BP, do some searches on BP and read those old posts related to this topic.
A few questions to ask yourself - why are you investing in RE? are you investing for cash flow or appreciation or both? where do you want to invest? how much do you have to invest? are you hands on? how much time do you have? do you mind giving up control to get ease of management? do you have trust in the providers? how do you verify your providers? what's your holding period? why aren't you investing locally when Pomona / Chino / IE is around your neck of the woods?
We all have different answers so proceed based on your answers.
I can only share what I've learned and my path - I bought turnkey because I didn't know better when I started. I didn't know BP existed when I started learning in 2011. I didn't want to spend the time to deal with local realtors / rehabbers / tenants (or out of state one for that matter) because I couldn't handle the stress of late night toilet/tenant calls and I didn't have the money. I know my return will be less but I was OK with that - I gain leverage from borrowed money and I have my tenants paying off the mortgage. If the turnkey providers did a good job on rehab, and my cash flow is sufficient, I should be able to make "some" money in a LONG run like 10+ years either through cash flow + mortgage pay down + "maybe" appreciation. I vetted providers by asking them questions, visiting the market, and checking their rehab quality. I check in with them regularly to see how things are doing. I have google keywords set up so I get general market update. I also have zillow setup to send me daily emails on new listing for sell or rents so I know how the market listing is going. It's not perfect because I still don't know Memphis market well but I count on my PM / provider to help me.
Can I do the same using a local realtor? I probably can do it now with a new market with the help from BPers. I'm not ready to invest in another market yet considering the market condition and my own personal situation.
Hope that helps and good luck making a decision and move forward.
Henry