Hi Ben - great questions - I start with a basic set of parameters that are typical for my investment area .. if I like what I see - I do a little more digging. I avoid analysis paralysis by understanding that I am loading up the expenses as more of a "just in case" scenario. If a deal just looks "OK" I will still play with the numbers to see what my break even point is and what would have to happen to get there - if there are too many red flags then I walk away - there are still many other factors that I will look at such as location, age of property, type of property , local comps, ARV , potential add-ons and other factors that would affect the cashflow and/or resell value.
On this particular subject property - it appears that everything is brand new which is one of the reasons I didn't add more for the Cap x - but I understand the importance of building it into numbers. Tenant moveouts are partially covered by repair & maintenance. I am aware of the PMI for life with FHA mortgages , which is one of the reasons I try to avoid FHA myself. He does not indicate if this will be FHA or Conventional though.
Overall - I like to see more than $100 / door in cash flow - I don't put a lot of stock into cap rates as it really more of comparison ratio of one property to another - it's the cash flow I like to see and I want to be sure it is making more for me than a (totally ) passive investment - I have to go - I am heading up our weekly meetup group today and need to head over to the meeting space - It was great sharing with you all .. I look forward to more engaging dialog.