Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Frank S.

Frank S. has started 6 posts and replied 18 times.

Post: Reverse 1031 Exchange

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

I found a property prior to selling one of my existing rentals.

Does anyone have experience or can advise me on doing a Reverse 1031?

Thanks!

Post: Starting in short term rentals.

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

@Shawn Marschke I started investing in STR's around mid December and I'm doing well, for now. Instead of a down payment and furnishings I bought ABNB stock. Another way to ride the trend that I think is a long term play for this business model. So, I'm hoping you all have good success in your STR businesses!

Post: College vs Real Estate??

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

This topic has come up so many times and you will get a variety of answers so this is my opinion only.

Go to college – get a degree - the world is moving at light speed with technology and change is guaranteed. How will you adapt to the world and stay relevant? It’s through education, continuous learning and adapting. If you don’t, you will be left behind.

If you don’t like engineering that’s OK get a business degree or minor in it. If you want to own your own business or be an investor then learn accounting, finance, marketing, etc. You need to know these things and they can only help you.

Also, going to college tells me you want to learn, you see things through to the end, when it gets tough or you don’t like a subject you persist because it has to get done. It’s more than a degree it tells people a lot about who you are and what you are capable of.

It can also open doors for you. Be intentional with who you friend, connect and network with.

That is only part of the answer. Opening doors is good but you should want more. Kick the door down and run through it. After the degree it becomes more about the hustle, drive, integrity, work ethic, never going to stop, work nights, work weekends, stop looking at twitter and research RE, Stocks, businesses instead.

My opinion. Good luck!

Post: Linville Gorge and Spruce Pine in NC

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

I know the area well. Great place for hiking, camping, mountain biking, winery and anything outside.

Check out Land Harbor – https://www.linvillelandharbor.com

Post: Use cash flow to pay off my SFR rental or invest in the S&P 500?

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

Before investing in the market you should have between 4-6 months of reserves and living expenses saved up. If you have a W2 job, do they offer you a 401k option with a match? If so, take advantage of it before investing on your own. 

With current world events, I would hold on to some cash right now and build up more reserves. I’m conservative and live by a simple rule – before you buy anything have an exit plan because you are going to be wrong – having the reserves and a solid  exit strategy can save you.

Post: Home Warranty – Are they worth it?

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

A couple of months ago we closed on a house and it had a home warranty through AHS. We had issues with our hot water heater that took almost 2 weeks and a lot of money out of our pocket. Today, we had issues with our AC and they barely cover anything. Worthless and very poor customer service from that company.

What is your experience with home warranties – are they worth it – of did they (sellers) purchase from a bad company?

Post: Please join me in roasting crappy Appraisers!

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Frank S.:

Great discussion! I have always questioned their independence and “non-objective” appraisals and comps. In my experience, I often feel like they are working for the other party (buying agent or bank) because some of the comps don’t make sense. I have the experience and know how to pull recent sold’s (closed public records sold) along with pictures to object to what they have but they won’t listen or even take into account what I found.

I would like a way to challenge the appraisal. Maybe there is and I don’t know?

 Challenging an appraisal may be illegal.

It is not illegal to challenge an appraisal if errors are discovered, however be advised, no appraisal is perfect and there is room allowed for small errors before an appraisal will be deemed deficient. The errors must be a) substantial to the result or b) so numerous that they illustrate incompetence. A couple of typos aint going to cut it. An appraisal that demonstrates an appraiser can't add and subtract might. An appraisal that demonstrates a difference in opinion between you and the appraiser is not going to cut it.

It is illegal to challenge the appraised value in all mortgage appraisals. It is illegal for the bank to do it. It is illegal for the borrower to do it. It is illegal for the realtor to do it. It is collusion if these parties conspire to do it.

Where everyone goes wrong on this issue, is the law allows the appraisal client (the bank) to request supplemental information from the appraiser post-submission of the appraisal report, for the purposes of providing further support of the value conclusion already made and delivered. This provision is widely misinterpreted, for obvious and self-serving reasons, as an open-season to challenge the value conclusion. Take a second and consider the circumstance of obtaining a mortgage appraisal in the first place - the entire point is to create a barrier between the valuation of the asset and the loan officer, according to the rule of law to do so - not because nobody other than the appraiser can figure out what the property is probably worth.

The absence of law enforcement has made the problem more widespread, to the point where people are challenging appraisals all the time. In the absence of law enforcement, each individual appraiser faced with the circumstance must navigate how to address challenge requests, often blatantly titled "Reconsideration Of Value Request" by the lender, borrower and realtor. Some lenders even have policies encouraging borrowers and inviting realtors (what the hell is the realtor doing in the loan office?). What most appraisers do, is bite the bullet and write a paragraph of nonsense saying they aren't going to change a damn thing and **** you, written in a much more polite and professional manner. The really stupid appraisers will actually conspire illegally with the bank, borrower and realtor and change the value (if I can add to this thread list of things stupid appraisers do, that might be the top of my list). The incredibly smart appraisers MIGHT take the time to explain this to the client, except by doing so, lenders usually call another appraiser the next time, seeing as they prefer to have their head in the sand while the sand is profitable. See no evil.

The influence on appraisers from loan brokers in the modern world is the telephone. Play ball or the phone stops ringing. Each appraiser actively working in the mortgage industry currently is therefore a) ignorant of the laws governing the profession - an act prohibited under USPAP or b) dishonest or c) both or d) doing the best they can while they suffer injustice and an impossible choice. I'd say option D is the most common one. It's 100% the appraisers fault and at the same time is 0% the appraisers fault. That last bit takes a few more pages of text to explain. It's also at the core of why I stopped being an appraiser. I have seen the evil and have walked away.

As far as the question about comps, why are you attempting to analyze comps??? Think hard. Answer honestly.

As far as your inclination that appraisers are working for the "other" party, I wonder at what point did you ever think it might be any other way??? Was it when the bank talked you into paying the fee for the appraisal? Is that when you thought you purchased an interest? Of course the appraiser is working for the bank. The appraiser is working only for the bank. And what that explains, is why the comps appear to be selected according to what the bank might want to see, maybe not what might make the most sense to another party. That is exactly what is happening, and also exactly as it should be. Your problem is you think you are entitled to more for your money than you are!!! (As a side note, the only reason the borrower receives a copy of the appraisal report today when they pay for it is because someone complained to the right person and a law was passed a few years ago - borrowers did not always get a copy, and the fact that everyone does now creates confusion over the rights of use.)

As far as the ability to pull data on your own - bravo! Each investor will need to become their own appraiser. Then when you have cash and don't need a bank, that skill will really come in handy as there are no social safety nets in place for cash buyers.

Thanks for the reply. I pull and analyze comps to compare my home to others and I’m pretty fair as evident that some of the flips sold first week or even weekend and they close, several for full asking price. Of course, I want more money and I fight for my right (and hard earned effort) to maximize my profit while balancing the need to move it quickly.

I had one house on a great quiet street, all new electrical, kitchen, master bath, floors…etc. One of his comps was a house on a four lane busy road that was not remodeled. I showed them a house similar to mine around the corner that was remodeled and sold (closed) within a couple of months of my listing. That was not one of his comps.

I only want them to be fair and consistent and that is my hang up with some…not all of them.

Post: Please join me in roasting crappy Appraisers!

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

Great discussion! I have always questioned their independence and “non-objective” appraisals and comps. In my experience, I often feel like they are working for the other party (buying agent or bank) because some of the comps don’t make sense. I have the experience and know how to pull recent sold’s (closed public records sold) along with pictures to object to what they have but they won’t listen or even take into account what I found.

I would like a way to challenge the appraisal. Maybe there is and I don’t know?

Post: How do I get started in investing in rental property in Detroit?

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

Be open to buying stocks – I know this is a RE forum – but I consider myself an investor. Take advantage of opportunities no matter what the asset class. Some good quality companies are on sale right now and could give you significantly better returns than RE. Do you homework and know how to manage risk and the potential downside. Always buy (RE or stocks) with an exit strategy first because if you are wrong, and it will happen with anything you buy, know when to get out to limit your loss.

Post: How are you handling Coronavirus cancellations?

Frank S.Posted
  • Investor
  • Simpsonville, SC
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 32

Great thread and read! The answers vary and you can manage your business as you want but in the end the customer will always be…well, I’l let Sam Walton finish that line, “There is only one boss. The customer. And he can fire everybody in the company from the chairman on down, simply by spending his money somewhere else.” Makes you think about the customer experience. It’s about them not us so think about win-win proposals that can benefit both parties.