Two tenants who are roommates have always been argumentative and difficult with me about following rules. I discovered they moved in two new roommates, a couple, under the radar a month ago.
I agreed to screen the couple to potentially add them to a new lease jointly and severally with the original two, and found neither has adequate verifiable income, and one has no credit history at all.
The original two will not agree with my terms to conditionally approve the couple, which are an additional 1-month security deposit (equalling 2 total) to cover my financial risk and a new 6-month lease vs continuing the month-to-month to have more stability. So, I delivered a 3-day perform or quit today to move out the unapproved occupants. I put it in an envelope and taped it to their door when nobody answered and took a video. I will follow up with a mailed letter. I would love them to all move out.
QUESTIONS:
1 Can I deny the couple's application for cause of non-verifiable income, when the original two have covered 100% of rent every month? I don't want non-qualified tenants there if the qualified ones move out!
2 Should I tell the applicant couple that there was a breakdown in the agreement over the additional security deposit and 6-month terms? @brandonturner says I need to send a letter telling applicants why they were denied. I've only communicated with the couple about their application, which I ran on apartments.com but didn't follow through with landlord verifications after seeing the income problems.
3 After 3 days (today is Tuesday, I believe that means Friday?) how do I successfully verify if the tenant performed my demand to remove the couple?
4 If not, then what? Move forward with filing an eviction?
Thanks to all of you with solid professional experience and advice to offer! I'm all ears.