@David Chapoell
Your calc is wrong. You never entered your down payment. You need to enter a % you’re putting down on the property. You mentioned $18k from a Heloc. I’m assuming that’s a 20% dp so you need to get that into your calc to make it accurate.
Also unless you’re getting seller help, or paying cash, or seller financing, closing costs are going to be more than $2k in my experience. Bank financing is expensive. My past 2 mortgages have been $10k and $12k in “closing costs”. Random things like doc prep, prepaid escrow, school taxes, inspections, flood certs, title company, attorney fees, etc etc. it adds up quick unless you can snag some seller help.
I have no idea your market, but I never run numbers at max rental amounts. If I think I can get $800 a month on a bad day and $900 on a good day for a unit, I always run the numbers at $800. It’s safe. If you do get fortunate and the market is hot, or it’s peak leasing season and you can get someone in there for $900 then great! You’re making extra cash. But prep for worse case scenarios and go from there. If the deal makes sense at your worse case scenario, then go for it and it may be better than you think if you can get those higher rental amounts!
For example. I have a 3 unit building that’s now finally 100% occupied. 2 units I knew I could get $700 and $750 for and I got them filled before COVID-19 hit. The other should be going for $900 in June/July aka peak season. But because of the crises I had a great applicant that I really wanted in, but they said they couldn’t afford the $900. So I settled and got an amazing tenant at $800. I’m not sweating over the $100 because I’ll never hear from this tenant ever again. Young IT professional straight out of college who can work from home and won’t lose their job. Plan worse case, and if you get best case then great!
Good luck man.