@Nerissa Marbury - Suggestion for avoiding this situation in the future... What I use is the following wording in my lease. This has eliminated all issues that I have had on the appliances as they become completely responsible for the issues and maintenance. This has held up in court in Marion county Indiana.
Appliances - The appliances have been supplied in complete working order. Appliances included are a refrigerator, electric stove, above stove microwave, garbage disposal and dish washer. The use of these appliances is not included in the rent. If Tenants wish to use these appliances, they agree to assume all responsibility for care and maintenance. Tenants agree to return the appliances in the condition supplied less any normal and reasonable use. If Tenants wish to use their own appliances, they may request that the owners’ appliance(s) be removed from the premises. Initials verify that the Tenants understand this paragraph.
I am not a lawyer nor am I giving legal advice by providing this information.