Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Dirk S.

Dirk S. has started 8 posts and replied 49 times.

Post: NYC House Hacking- Multifamily Townhouse

Dirk S.Posted
  • New York City, NY
  • Posts 53
  • Votes 12
Quote from @Frank Chin:

Dirk:

I've done RE investing in NYC for nearly 40 years. I looked into rent controlled and rent stabilized properties and concluded it's too much uncertainty. I instead did foreclosures and pre-foreclosures where returns are more certain and requiring a lot less analysis and done very well, in fact much better. It takes a bit more work to find.

I know a good friend of mine who bought a 16 unit rental, all rent stabilized, with a free unit to the super. He kicked the super out, moved into the unit himself, then rented units out to un-documented immigrants increasing the rents beyond what's allowed, and replaced about half of the tenants that way. Told the undocumented tenants if they complained, he would report them to the authorities and have them deported.  Apparently, the doctor who sold him the building was so impressed with what he did, bought the building back for several times what it was sold for. 

I think my method of investment is less risk and more ethical. 


 Frank

I dont have a problem with a disagreeing post, and you say you did well doing foreclosures, good for you. But if you are implying that all landlords who own rent stabilized units act like your friend, or that I was implying to use such methods, then I have a problem with that.

Besides, you are saying your friend made out very well, so this kind of contradicts your original statement that RS is not profitable.

Post: NYC House Hacking- Multifamily Townhouse

Dirk S.Posted
  • New York City, NY
  • Posts 53
  • Votes 12
Quote from @Frank Chin:
Quote from @Aleksandra Serebrenik:
Quote from @Christian D.:

You can definitely find 2-3 families in Brooklyn for under $1MM. With the new HSTPA I have seen 6-unit RS buildings recently listed for under $1MM (i.e., Sunset Park, Ridgewood, Glendale). I believe if you can pick up one of these RS buildings for a significant discount it will pay off in the long run. I believe you are now eligible to only take back one RS apartment for yourself after acquisition.

I purchased a triplex in Brooklyn with an FHA loan almost two years ago. I would advise purchasing with the intent to live in one of the units to help supplement your rent. Unless you are leveraging more than 65% on acquisition, it's unlikely the property is going to cash flow.


 What is RS? And do these areas still offer interesting opportunities in late 2023? Sunset Park, Ridgedale, Glendale...


 Aleksandra:

RS is for Rent Stabilization, where they regulate rent increases on rental units rendering RS properties unprofitable. 

See: RS Rent Stabilization


 I would not say that rent stabilized properties per se are unprofitable. It is a bit more complex. You can buy RS properties right now that are at least according to their listing profitable, because they are also priced lower. The main motivation for investors to buy those properties is the goal of eventually turning the rent stabilized apartments into free market apartments over time, increasing market value of the property that way. That has long worked successfully (and again, the property does not have to be cash flow negative at the beginning, but you will be expecting to invest into modernization). A word of caution though, investing in RS properties also is tied to the legal and political situation. Here in NYC a lot of RS property owners are now in trouble because the laws shifted unexpectedly and they cant make their apartments free market.

I am looking for an organization that supports landlords and property owners across all their needs: tenant relations, financial, legal, other advice. I am not from the US originally and in my home country there is such a thing, a national organization with offices in every major city, who provide information and services to landlords and home owners in general, for a small annual fee. 

I googled this and found 2 so far (let me know what you think):

https://landlordassociation.com/membership.html#join   (specializes in tenant screening and management)

https://www.american-apartment-owners-association.org/regist...    (seem to provide a broad range of services, closest to what I am thinking)

Of course, this website is phenomenal and I have benefitted greatly already, but still wonder if there is such a thing.

Quote from @Ned J.:

Don't you just love HOA's? They can be absolutely horrible nit picking , nosey, in all your business PITA, fine crazy whackos.....or completely absent, do nothings deadbeats.

I would push HARD on the HOA....over and over and over..... its their job to enforce the rules and take action if they are not followed. Just when you need an HOA to be aggressive, they aren't....

I dont think "sealing up" your doors etc is going to do anything. From my understanding bed bugs dont travel far, so I dont think they are crawling from the common area and into your unit.  I would be aggressive with regular pest control service. 


Your second version fits our HOA perfectly. Total corruption and incompetence. Yes, pushing as much as I can. Trying to get others involved. I am noticing there is a sort of apathy with some other owners, its difficult...

Actually I read they can crawl 30 feet in one night. The exterminator seems good, one thing at least in the positive column.

Quote from @Matt Devincenzo:

I doubt that they are spreading themselves or that sealing up your unit like bubble boy will prevent the bed bugs. What is likely happening is she has them in her unit, or on things she brings in like you mentioned. Then when she is out in common areas some end up left behind and other residents pick them up when they are using the space later. That's how they spread, by someone sitting in a chair where they are, or laundry with them on it getting washed and they drop off. So unfortunately the only way to resolve this is to first stop any new BB coming in, and then treat to eliminate the existing infestation. Even if she never brings another item home, if she hangs out where they are then she can end up bringing them back in on her clothes.i


 Of course that is completely agreed, however the big problem here is that this is some sort of obsession, hoarders do what they do - bring in more trash, its like an addiction. It is with the building lawyers but I am not hopeful that will change her ways. The best way I see is hitting her in the pocket book. And protect my unit best I can. The hallways here are not something where people hang out, they come off the elevator and go to their units.Unfortunately her unit is right across from  of the elevator. Could we have picked them up by walking there? Sure, its possible but I still think they walk around into other units more likely. To further protect myself I now take the elevator to one floor below and walk the stairs up which avoids her area. 

Quote from @JD Martin:

How are you going to prove the neighbor brought bed bugs in that spread to your unit? 


There is a clear timeline of infestation, the exterminator at the time reported that the hoarder  was infested 6 months ago (and it was not addressed by management). Then in July it had spread to her direct neighbor to the left, and subsequently  it hit the hallways, and finally me who is further down the hallways. Of course there is no ultimate proof, but that is a strong evidence. I would assume that her side would argue what you are saying though - this is why I would like to know if there is anybody, lawyer or not, who has dealt with this before.

Thanks for every reply. the condo board (HOA) is trying, but they are not getting anywhere fast because the hoarder is not cooperating. As mentioned is with the building lawyers right now. This is probably going to take quite some time. In the meantime she continues to do her thing, risking more bed bugs spreading.

Therefore, apart from legal options, I would like the HOA to pay for reinforcing my apartment door. It is out of alignment and there are gaps the bugs could walk through. I also want to insulate all around the frame so it creates an airtight seal. I think this is the HOA's responsibility, because I believe the door is part of the common areas in a condo building, and they should protect me from future infestations, since the issue with the hoarder looks like its going to be a while. Additionally the agent was negligent, not addressing the situation for over 6 months. Is it reasonable to ask the HOA for this measure?

I have a situation in a condo building (100 units) where on the floor where I own a unit lives a hoarder who constantly brings in trash from the street and with that bed bugs into the building. Management has been slow and ineffective to address the issue and now they spread to multiple units including mine. 

The condo is bearing the cost of the cleanup for now, but my big concern is that the hoarder will keep doing this and my unit is going to be at risk long term, affecting rental/sales value.. Management has involved the condo lawyer now because she is not cooperating, and also started involving Adult Protective Services. All this will take a long time probably. Can I directly sue the hoarder (she owns her place free and clear and is current on all payments), as well as condominium, managing agent, maybe even the long term building extermination service who knew about this and failed to resolve it? Any lawyer who has direct experience with this issue please let me know.

I could join up with other affected unit owners.

Post: Tax implications on sale of principal residence

Dirk S.Posted
  • New York City, NY
  • Posts 53
  • Votes 12
Quote from @Michael Plaks:

@Dirk S.

1 - Yes, and it does not matter short or long term

2 - $0 in this hypothetical scenario, except for your other income such as W2

3 - Exclusion of $250k - same as Federal. Offsetting capital gains with past carryforward losses - same as Federal. Other state issues may exist however.

4 - Yes, as long as you don't exceed 3 years even by one day and you don't move back.

Bonus - You have 3 years to find a spouse and double your exemption ;)


 Excellent bonus point. Thanks a bunch (to all who answered). I confirmed my theory by simulating the scenario in Turbotax as well. This forum is awesome!

Post: Tax implications on sale of principal residence

Dirk S.Posted
  • New York City, NY
  • Posts 53
  • Votes 12
Quote from @Basit Siddiqi:

I often find that sometimes people also disregard the Net Investment Income Tax when calculating the estimated amount of tax upon sale.

Also, don't forget about any improvements made to the house over those 20 years.


 Thanks, can you tell me more about this " Net Investment Income Tax"?
"