@Al D. 2 properties in Memphis here. So let me get this straight - you had a vacancy and your PM never cleaned the unit? He's showing it when there is garbage in the unit, it smells, and the previous tenants crap is there....FOR 4 MONTHS? My PM in Memphis renovated a town house in 3 weeks! You talk to him and he tells you that in his vast experience it's never stopped people from renting in a timely way? 4 months isn't timely...THIS PM IS KILLING YOU.
-You have lost a MINIMUM of 6 MONTHS RENT and probably more by the time you get this unit cleaned, find a new PM and find a renter. That's $4500-$4900 in my Memphis C-class units PLUS the cost of the turnover and fees for a new PM. So $8400 and counting....
-You are attracting the bottom of the barrel renter when/if someone decides to rent a smelly, garbage filled house/apt. C'mon man these properties are risky enough already in Memphis.
FIRE THIS PM IMMEDIATELY and try to salvage the second half of the years rents.