Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Account Closed

Account Closed has started 88 posts and replied 149 times.

Post: Asking Property Manager for Contractor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Stewart Guthrie:

Well said Alex

 Ok, it's either my English is not good or some major misunderstanding keep popping out one after another. Heard my idea, i find a PM, told that person i would like to build trust & relationship with him to see if i should let that person manage my future properties. So i ask who is their contractors so i know what advice in repair & replace i should expected. After all i want to know should i trust in this PM & his/her contractors. Yes, i will ask for their track record, system in place, experience and other criteria in looking for a PM company. As for the other investment i had said, it mean that since i know & trust the contractor, i may want to directly call them and ask them to renovate a property for a flip purpose, or something similar. That's all. I failed to see how this misunderstanding happened or what i did wrong here. I simply cannot see it.

Post: Asking Property Manager for Contractor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Fred Heller:

If I'm reading this correctly, what you're asking is that the PM turn over his playbook to you, for free. Why not just walk into some local restaurant and ask for the recipe for their special dish? That's essentially what you're doing.

PMs spend years cultivating relationships with contractors. This benefits you because it means the PM gets lower prices and priority service when there is something that needs to be addressed. And you just expect him to turn over the fruits of these years of work to you, for free? For all he knows you're planning to use his information to start your own property management business. Or, more likely, use his information to self-manage and cut him out.

I'm not saying that my contractor list rises to the level of a "trade secret." If you were my client, you'll see their invoices when I bill you for the work. And I would be happy to have you use any of my contractors for any your flipping projects. But to do an end run around me where my contractors are concerned; well, that's just not cool.

"Friendly and trusted" runs both ways. I would consider you neither if you demanded that I "give away" my contractor list as a prerequisite to doing business with me. It's not a good way to start a relationship and I would politely suggest that you take care that the door doesn't hit you in the *** on the way out.

 Ok, it's either my English is not good or some major misunderstanding keep popping out one after another. Heard my idea, i find a PM, told that person i would like to build trust & relationship with him to see if i should let that person manage my future properties. So i ask who is their contractors so i know what advice in repair & replace i should expected. After all i want to know should i trust in this PM & his/her contractors. Yes, i will ask for their track record, system in place, experience and other criteria in looking for a PM company. As for the other investment i had said, it mean that since i know & trust the contractor, i may want to directly call them and ask them to renovate a property for a flip purpose, or something similar. That's all. I failed to see how this misunderstanding happened or what i did wrong here. I simply cannot see it. 

Post: Asking Property Manager for Contractor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Robert Farris:

@Account Closed, If you're using the PM company to only gain access to their contractors and not using the PM company, common sense tells me this may be bad business. If the PM company is using public contractors, then maybe they would share that information but you probably wouldn't get as good of a deal as you would with the PM company involved.

Why don't you just call a bunch of contractors and get bids, ask as many questions as you desire. Most contractors I would think are willing to give advice and talk your ear off.

This is my thinking:

I would like to find a PM company that would use their contractors to get my property "renter ready" in a timely manner, have renters immediately move in, then manage it for me. 

This to me, would be a win-win situation.

@Alex Craig, is this the type of win-win situation you are talking about? Do most PM companies offer this type of service?

Good luck!

I don't know what i had indicate that saying i'm using PM for their contractor contract only. I'm actually going to hire a PM company to manage my portfolio but i want to know their contractors too for the repair & fix purpose, and if possible different investment purpose such as fix & flip, or BRRRR. All in all, i want a PM to manage my properties & if possible their contractors also help me in different investment. What is your suggestion Robert if i want to do an investment such as wrap or sub2 with a PM & contractors involved, i'm very new here?

Post: Asking Property Manager for Contractor?

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Stewart Guthrie:

Hello Dante,

If the property owner share's the contractor's information, it isn't very likely that the contractor will give you the same pricing that he gives a property manager.  

As soon as a PM and contractor find that they work well with each other, the contractor can focus on doing what he/she, (usually), does best, getting work done, instead of selling the next job or paying for SEO or Pay Per Click Ads.  Those marketing resources, (in funds and time), make up the volume discounts that the property manager realizes as they pass more work along to the contractor than the vast majority of private citizens, or even a small or medium sized flipper or landlord.

Obviously, a large flipper/investor on BP can generate as much or more work than a small or medium sized property management company, which would also translate into more aggressive pricing for them as well.  

There are differences, however; a contractor working with a PM is likely only going to see a few, full blown remodels a year, whereas a flipper is going to live and breath that kind of work.  The flipper contractor has a better grip on his scheduling, (DIY Network shows notwithstanding), and the homes are usually vacant, where a PM contractor is usually responding to breakfix repair or preventative maintenance and must be able to work around a tenant's work schedule and household belongings.

You should become a HUGE flipper, and then you can get great pricing, or own your own construction company, (which is where a bunch of our BP colleagues are going).

 Well i do plan to flip some properties in the future but currently i'm more into rental like i always wanted to do. Anyway do you think it is a good idea to ask my property manager for their contractors so when i hire my property manager i know where my money is going and i can actually get some advice on rehab, renovate and fix/repairs for my property? 

PS: I lose a property management company trust because they don't give their contractors away. No big deal as i'm searching for a friendly, reliable & trusted company to manage my future portfolio anyway. 

Post: Property Manager Revenue

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Jim Pellerin:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

Not a home inspection. My property management company does an annual inspection to make sure the tenant is taking care of the property. We charge the owner a fee for that service. The maintenance and repair services income is the difference between what the property management company charges the owner and what they pay their contractors.

 So instead of calling the property manager, they have a system in place where the manager just need to check the tenant once a year?

 Yes. But we charge the owner.

 Oh one more question Jim. Do you think most property management company are reluctant to give away their contractors' companies to investor such as myself?

Post: Architect/ Property Manager for rehab & renovation

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Jim Adrian:

Small firm should be less expensive and provide the same quality.  I would find an architect that focuses on residential.

 Thank Jim

Post: Creative Condos Unit Revenue

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8

Apartment and condos are all under strata title meaning there is a community board or HOA manage the entire building. So in that case, if i have some condos units in the building, what are other creative income can i generated aside from the usual rental and fees?

Post: Property Manager Revenue

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Jim Pellerin:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

Not a home inspection. My property management company does an annual inspection to make sure the tenant is taking care of the property. We charge the owner a fee for that service. The maintenance and repair services income is the difference between what the property management company charges the owner and what they pay their contractors.

 So instead of calling the property manager, they have a system in place where the manager just need to check the tenant once a year?

 Yes. But we charge the owner.

 Thank Jim

Post: Property Manager Revenue

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Jim Pellerin:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Jim Pellerin:

Property managers will make money as follow:

1. Placement services

2. Monthly management fees

3. Yearly inspection fees

4. Maintenance and repair services

My experience is that property management companies mark up the cost of their maintenance and repairs. They either charge a project management fee directly or they just bury it into the cost of the repair. I would just ask them how much they mark up the cost of the maintenance and repairs. Now some property managers don't mark up the costs.

 Yearly inspection? You mean property management company have a home inspection service? And the maintenance and repair services income is made from their contractors, right (That's the point in having them)?

Not a home inspection. My property management company does an annual inspection to make sure the tenant is taking care of the property. We charge the owner a fee for that service. The maintenance and repair services income is the difference between what the property management company charges the owner and what they pay their contractors.

 So instead of calling the property manager, they have a system in place where the manager just need to check the tenant once a year?

Post: Rich Dad Epilogue

Account ClosedPosted
  • Student
  • Null
  • Posts 149
  • Votes 8
Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Aaron Mazzrillo:

Back when that book was written there were no doc loans. They called them liar loans and basically they were funded by what you told them you earned and nobody ever questioned it or asked for any proof of income, bank statements or filed taxes. 

 So that would mean this method the book mentioned will no longer work & is not one of the above methods i mentioned.

 There is plenty of money out there just waiting for an enterprising entrepreneur to put it to work. When you make the decision that you will only rely on institutional financing, you decide that you want to live a life of mediocrity and that you will be controlled by others decisions of what is right for them regardless of of illogical that is.

When you make the decision that you will work to find private lenders who share your vision and want to help you realize it, you will find more than enough money to satisfy your needs. I closed a deal last Friday. I paid $135K. My private lender funded $135K. He then called me and told me how I should fix it up and sell it. So, not only did I get almost 100% financing (I have to pay 2 pts and closings costs), I also get the sage advice of a guy who has flipped more than 500 houses.

There isn't a bank on the planet that is going to suggest to you how to run your deal. Their only mantra is; Make the payment on time.

Already planned to use other method than the traditional & boring bank loan because i just love to use my brain, that's why i'm into real estate. Aaron, can i assume most of your deals are flipping and may i asked do you used a property manager/ Architect to handle the rehab because it can save you time for other important matter instead of being there on the scene?

 I run a full spectrum real estate business; I hold, wholesale and retail. Just depends on the deal. I play in the entry level market and it is all pretty much straight off the shelf from Home Depot. First time home buyers are easy to please because they don't really know what they want. They just want to stop paying rent or living with mom. Therefore, an architect is never called for unless you plan on doing some additional square footage which is not part of my business model. 

I'm a turn and burn kind of investor. I don't like being bogged down on a rehab for months and I detest working with government entities like code enforcement and the building department. Surprisingly, most of my best deals are clean and fix, then sell fast below market, especially in this hot market. I am doing a rehab now that is costing me $6K. New counter tops, some paint, fix a window, replace the tilt up garage door with a roll up, and some other minor tune ups. 

When inventory is low, there is zero reason to do a full blown rehab. I think most investors do it because they don't know any better and/or they just want to impress their friends with the pictures they post on Facebook. Why spend $25K to sell for $200K when you can spend $5K and sell for $185K? Less in, more out and a faster sale because it is "sweat equity" deal. First time home buyers will fall for that gimmick again and again in a hot market. 

As for the design, I don't really get involved too much. Most houses I don't look at before I buy and probably only see once before I list to sell them. It is the contractor's job to walk it and write up a rehab proposal. Why do I need to be there? I don't know how to swing a hammer. I know how to write checks so I stick with what I know. He does the work and sends me pictures. 

Real estate can be a completely hands off business, but most are too scared to actually take that next step. They think they need to micromanage every aspect of the buying, fixing and selling. Sit home, buy houses cheap, send your contractor out to fix them and have your listing agent do the walk-thrus to tell you what needs to be touched up. If you hire a listing agent, make him/her work for the money. He/she should be perfectly capable of doing a punch list and even picking out colors/textures that will get the house sold. If not, get yourself a new agent.

Just to clarify, because it is a fix & clean, it is unreasonable to have a property manager/ Architect because your contractor will write up a small rehab proposal and send you the after-math pictures. And when you sell your property through a listing agent, that person also happened to know about rehab too. And i apologized but i don't really get "when inventory is low, there is zero reason to do a full blown rehab."