Hi everyone!
My dilemma is, buy an old house (BRRRR) or buy a brand new home and rent it.
I know, it will broadly depends on my goals. So, here are some cons and pros I can think of:
PROS:
- Old house can be cheaper, specially if the owner is distressed and we are able to get a good deal.
- We can fix it and refinance it (getting back the initial investment)
- New home will need very very very low maintenance (specially Cap Ex.)
- The new home can be rented a bit higher than the old house
CONS:
- Additional time I need to spend in the old house to repair. In this case, for me, fill be very hard (my job demands me 60+ hours/week and I will have only weekends to work on it), unless I have a partner to work on the deal, will be too hard for me.
- Old house will have constant maintenance issues and Cap Ex will need to be a special consideration.
- New home we cannot refinance and get our investment back. Maybe after a year if appreciation goes up like crazy (but I prefer not to count on that).
- New home will be more expensive vs. the higher rent. At 20% down, the ROI will be close to 8-10%, which for the old house will be higher (infinite if we got our investment back).
- In Portland, OR, where I am from, I realized many new homes come with HOA ($100+ in many cases)
Comments? Ideas? Anything I may have missed?
I would like to see other people ideas and approaches. As I mentioned early, it may have to do with each person's goals. For myself, my goal is to buy and hold for very long term.
Thanks a lot!
Daniel