Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Damian Callaghan

Damian Callaghan has started 6 posts and replied 20 times.

Post: Buying a college property

Damian CallaghanPosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 7

Hey there - I’m looking for any creative ways to buy property near  my sons chosen college. This is nothing to do with getting in state fees as we are already in state. This is a way to joint invest with my son, not throw $15k a year away on renting for his 2 years at college and a long term investment. 

The 20% deposit is always a killer - tips and tricks welcome. Also guidance on. Using in trust or in his name 

Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
Quote from @Damian Callaghan:

Even if the tenant signed the lease and paid the first month's rent, you still have to make a good faith effort to find a new tenant. You can only hold the tenant liable up until the point the replacement tenant takes over. That's pretty standard practice. Unless your lease specifically authorizes you to keep the security deposit as a penalty, I recommend you only charge the tenant for the days the unit sits vacant.


 Seems absolutely fair and what I agreed. 

Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
Quote from @Damian Callaghan:

It helps to have a written policy before this situation occurs, but you are on the right track.

You've held the property off the market for them, so they need to take responsibility for backing out.

Tell them you'll hold the deposit and put the property back on the market. You'll only hold them liable for however long it takes to place the new tenant. If the original tenant was going to rent on June 1st and you find a new tenant to start renting June 11th, then you would deduct ten day of rent from the deposit and refund the remainder.


 I was concerned what my rights were with regards to the 1 month security deposit and if I was in my rights to keep it. In other word they forfeit their deposit for changing their mind. 

I went back and reviewed the contract and it states.

1. $2600 security deposit would be taken at time of contract signature

2. $2600 first month rent would be collected at time or signature. 

Even tho it states the above I agreed to delay the first month until after tbr HOA approval. I have text confirming this was I good faith.

Given we had collected monies per the contract and following some further research I am now thinking the tenant came off OK even if I do keep the deposit (which sounds legal) for the following reasons 

1. If then had paid both lots of $2600 I think I am entitled to keep both 

2. Given we entered a contract I believe the tenant is actually liable for the entire year!!!!!!!!

reading the fine print I believe they are supposed to provide written request to cancel the contract and only then we agree terms by which I am prepared to allow the contract to end prematurely.


I intend to call an attorney so I have one on call (I have some other passive income investments I am about to close and think some advice and structured contracts may make sense in a pay per enquiry or letter would be a good thing). I want direction on actual terms to point to which confirm the tenant is responsible and what I want from a termination perspective. 

We are about to rent our home and move in to a bigger family home. I found a tenant and we both signed a contract. I am in a HOA that had some stipulations. The intent was to take 1 month rent and 1 month as a security deposit but I just took 1 mth until they got approved by the HOA. I did open a separate bank account and deposited the 1 month. There was a fair bit of back and forth as the tenant didn't have a SSN and the HOA wanted background checks but the tenant had lived on the same development for 2yrs. They were eventually able to provide evidence of good standing and background check from their current mgmt agent. I did agree to give full refund of anything went wrong with hoa applications. Nothing did! But the client txt to say their current mgmt company and landlady made a mistake and they don't have to vacate their current property. In other-words mistake or change or mind. I am reviewing the contracts but wanted to ask the forum on if I am obliged to refund the deposit… one additional point. I have offered to give a full refund if I find a tenant before their expected move in date - if I am not out of pocket I am inclined to be fair. This is my first time as a landlord and this makes for awkward circumstances but it is also a business and not a charity - where do I stand?

Quote from @Devin Peterson:

What kind of business? Just curious?


 Happy to discuss further if you think you can service this loan. Direct message me 

Quote from @Bonnie Griffin Kaake:

@Damian Callaghan   Have you considered doing cost segregation on the other properties you own? It is like getting a free loan from the IRS. If you didn't have Federal taxes to pay on the other properties it just might give you some wiggle room for further investing and leveraging what you do have. 


this is new to me. I will have to investigate this further to better understand how it could help 

thanks for the suggestion 
I was told the economy and ad I just acquired another property recently. And the value is small. But my credit and PnL is strong. I was informed the economy is making n lenders edgy with two loans in quick succession 



Quote from @Scott Wolf:
Quote from @Damian Callaghan:

Actually this is Sarasota area - I wasn't anticipating getting in to the commercial space but an opportunity came up and so I went with it. The first load went OK but I just have another opportunity in hand and trying to find another commercial lender. One think I have noticed is that commercial lenders don't like small loan amounts - I am looking for $137K with 20% down. So I need a small commercial lender. Any recommendations welcome - or creative financing ideas. I could pay cash but would leave me tight and need some wiggle room

Damian, why isn't your current lender interested?  I'd be happy to try to assist with more info.

@Damian Callaghanundefined


Chris - thanks for the recommendation. How would one go about finding a private lender?

So what you are saying is investors are taking short term hit on cash flow before a refi when rates adjust???  To this end of you have 4 properties at 6% and rates go down to 4% are you allowed and does it make sense to re Fi then all at same time assuming there is the collateral 


Quote from @Christopher Watson:

Yep...higher interest rates absolutely kill what little cash flow you may be able to earn.  Adjust down your 7% to a 4% (old rates) and you see what I mean.  Surely someone else will add other variables to keep in mind.


Post: Mid Term Market

Damian CallaghanPosted
  • Posts 21
  • Votes 7
As it happens I am looking out of state in NC


Quote from @Jon Puente:

Hey Damian,

I would use 15% as an average for vacancy on MTR when doing calculations.  The truth is this:  You have plenty of time to find the next tenant and ideally, you will have done all the necessary repairs ahead of time to make the property "rent ready", so you will not need to do repairs in between tenants. 

I think 15% is VERY conservative.  I am doing an MTR coming soon in 2023 and my property manager has 100% occupancy, no issues at all. It also depends on the market you are in... I am in Charlotte, NC and its white hot here with real estate in general. 

I would ask PM's in your area who specialize in that space and get an accurate reading for your region.  I wouldn't think St. Pete would have any issues at all with occupancy.

Great Question!