Quote from @Huong Luu:
side question to this: Do you think rent control encourages renters to stay renters, thus making more houses on the market for investors?
The longer a tenant stays in a rent controlled unit, the harder it is for them to leave, especially in appreciating markets. With each year that goes by, they are getting a better 'deal' on the cost of housing. I don't think this helps investors at all; for a property to change hands, there has to be something for the landlord to gain.
Here's a real world-example of the net impact of today's decision on one of my properties, a 6-plex in Moncton (all 1BDRM). Market rent (which has escalated considerably in the last 2 years) is now $850 including utilities. I've been applying $20-$50 increases over the past few years, but kept rents flat during COVID to help tenants out. My average rent is $659. I had a $100 rent increase scheduled to go into effect on April 1st; all units would still be way below market, and all tenants were staying on. Now, my average permitted increase will be $25. From an NOI perspective, the delta is $5,400 in year 1 which, at a 6CAP, translates to a decrease in value of $90,000. I have one tenant that has been in the building for 34 years. She will never leave and will never pay market rent. My costs go up and the allowed rent increase doesn't cover inflation. So, as time goes on, I am subsidizing housing costs.