Thanks for all the input/advice. I feel like it's a good deal that makes sense, but obviously several others on here feel differently. I agree there is always risk with tenants, the quality of the rehab work, the area, taxes in that area, etc. I think I covered my bases by calling the assessors office to get accurate property tax info, had a home inspector go through both units thoroughly since I could not be there, and also found a local PM that said these units should be easy to re rent if the current tenants left. Also, the current tenants have been there for 3 months so far and the inspector said they had been keeping the place very neat and clean. One tenant is a disabled veteran which I like because it means guaranteed money for rent. Again, my real original question with starting this post was about whether its a good idea to pay cash for a deal from a taxation perspective. But as many here pointed out, taxes are inevitable, and if I'm paying them then it means I'm making money.