Hey guys! My first flip has had TWO full price offers back out on bad inspections. In both cases the housing inspector said the foundation needed further evaluation (but of course went on to add superlatives that I personally don't think they are qualified to say). In case 1 - the couple sought a contractor to inspect the foundation, who's report didn't speak to the status of the current foundation, but instead just provided them a $40,000 quote to REPLACE the foundation. In case 2, the couple just backed out without seeking further evaluation.
SHOCKED by this "bad foundation" knowledge, I sought a foundation expert myself to come tell me what is wrong, and he disagreed ENTIRELY with both housing inspectors. He said the foundation is "performing well, and will for many years to come in its current state". He said one inspector was out of line in his assessment that the foundation was "poor and structurally compromised" - and said he had no basis for saying that. He said the house is "safe". And both inspectors noted the foundation as a "safety concern". He even said he's buy the house personally without concern, and the suggestion to replace it entirely was "silly". The second inspector even insisted the house be retrofitted for earthquakes - but its a brick foundation. You can't even DO that with a brick foundation.
The guy I used is a guy who only BUILDS and INSPECTS foundations - he was referred to me by the leading foundation repair company in SoCal! These housing inspectors are jack of all trades, masters of none. Do I have any recourse here?! They've lost me TWO offers. The first inspector even went as far as to list the wiring as "knob and tube" - when I don't have knob and tube (in fact I rewired the whole house). He said my wall heaters aren't vented (they are, and through the roof, you can plainly see the vents from the outside of the house). He said I don't have carbon monoxide detectors (I do, they are carbon monoxide/smoke detectors).
Are these people just allowed to blatantly lie?