Hey @Blair Boan
I'm in Clemson and have invested in Greenville, so I'm pretty familiar with the market. If nothing else, this exercise is worthwhile to do so that you can figure out the pieces of what really makes a good deal.
The bottom line question you need to ask yourself is "How do I plan to profit on this deal?"
For me, it should fall into one of 2 categories:
1. Current income from the rent
2. Future equity from resale.
It's best to have the deal work just from #1. Your deal doesn't have great income numbers. In fact, I'm willing to bet it'll be very negative.
$1,300 x 50% (likely expenses) = $650/month net operating income.
If you bought the property for $190,000 and put $38,000 down (20%) and borrowed $152,000 at 4%, your payment would be $725/month.
$650 - $725 = $-75/month or $-900/year. Ouch. And that's before paying interest on your HELOC for the down payment.
So we know #1 - current income won't work unless you get it a lot cheaper. But what about #2 - future equity?
Lots are selling for $112,000. So we can't tear down your house and make any money at $190,000.
What about adding on? If your house is 1,200 sqft, can you add on 1,000 sqft wing? At $100/sqft cost, you'd add $100,000 to your $190,000 purchase, plus carrying and closing cost + remodel cost of the existing house. So you'd be well over $300,000 cost, maybe $350,000 or so, with a 2,200 sqft remodeled house. If you can resell for 200/sqft that could work ($440,000 value), but is that possible? I'd be a little nervous.
That's about all the possibilities I can think of. It doesn't seem like a great deal, and unless you have the capital to do a big add-on remodel and unless the market will support it, I'd pass.
The good news is that there are always more deals. keep hunting! Best of luck.