Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Clayton Silva

Clayton Silva has started 24 posts and replied 440 times.

Post: Don't know which direction to take - analysis paralysis

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

Hey Ashley! While definitely frustrating to hear about the unpermitted garage and the headache that would cause, you definitely have a good problem to have overall!  We specialize in investment lending and do a bit of advising as well to help clients determine what works best for their scenario.  I would love to chat more about your situation because there are a lot of factors that would be impossible to consider here such as importance of cash flow vs appreciation, how your income situation looks (tax benefits can play a major role in investing decision making) and so on.  I personally live in CA as well and invest in NC and AZ and know how hard it was to make the jump into long distance investing but honestly, I have never looked back!  Would love to connect and be a sounding board for some of your ideas!

Post: Recommended HELOC's or best short term debt for scaling

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

Hey Darian! I invest in Fayetteville actually and used to live there (was stationed there for a few years). We have a lot of different HELOC options and I would be more than happy to chat about those options with you!

Post: Financing for land leased properties

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

What kinds of properties are these, how are they being used, and how much time is left on the land leases?  I ran into this recently with another client of ours, and while doable, the land leases definitely complicate things.  Is there an opportunity to buy out any of the land leases?  Who are the lessors?

Post: Caps on Utility Bills for MTR Guests?

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

Definitely not a bad idea at all.  I would check the local landlord/tenant laws to ensure the feasibility of that, but I totally get your frustration.  Had a similar experience with an Airbnb in AZ where our solar went out and we didn't notice until we got a $600 electric bill for AC usage! 

Post: SFH house hacking property management

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

He Jake, do you already have a property in mind that you own? Or are you looking to purchase one?  Not sure how much computer availability you'll have but I have started to self manage my properties (even from CA to NC) and it is not nearly as difficult as I thought it would be.  I personally use Turbotenant and it has been awesome so far with very supportive customer service!

Post: Alabama Communit Banks for Land Loan for Build to Rent (BTR)

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

While we are not a local community bank we can definitely assist with refinancing out of your construction loan into more permanent financing in AL!  Are you looking to have each property on separate notes or all under one blanket loan?

Post: Is REI just taking out HELOC after HELOC?

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281
Quote from @John McKee:

A heloc is only used on your primary residence.  Most investors think they can take out helocs on all their rentals but that is not true.  What I have done in the past is use the heloc to buy the second property with all cash which includes the heloc and some cash that I have in the bank.  Once the deal is completed then I can take my time to put a mortgage on it and pull cash out.   Once I pull the money out of the second property I immediately pay off the Heloc until I'm ready to use it again for that 3rd property.  Now I'm fortunate to have a very large Heloc to do all cash deals but you get the idea.


 Actually we can offer HELOCs on investment properties as well 👍🏼 they are a pretty cool product and can be fixed rate

Post: How do I grow and keep things safe?

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

Hey Ray, sounds like a great problem to have! Because of the nature of our business, we do a lot of advising for clients who are new and experienced in the real estate market.  We can go over your goals and how best to structure your portfolio.

Post: HELOC - Trouble Finding a Lender

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281

Is the property in KS? 

What is the value, and what do you owe?

What kind of property is it? Multi or Single?

We can do investment HELOCs up to 70% LTV.

Post: My 100k house vs 100k in the S&P 500 (16 years later)

Clayton Silva#1 Personal Finance ContributorPosted
  • Lender
  • California
  • Posts 446
  • Votes 281
Quote from @K S.:

A turnkey home for 100k renting for 1k (1% rule) would net you worse than the stock market 16 years later. I went back through my 1099s and calculated my return and estimated closing costs, federal taxes, capital gains tax, depreciation recapture etc for my coming sale. Also, most people won't mention that many homes need to be renovated before the sale which cost me around $25,000.

SFH: 160k cash + 115k appreciation after sales fees and taxes over 16 years = $275,000 total earned after sale.

S&P: 580k -80,000 capital gains tax = $500,000

If you had a mortage, you'd be worse off and scraping by for the next 30 years, Ouch!, that's no fun to realize 30 years later.

S&P 500 almost doubled the returns of the SFH over the last 16 years yet I still argue with people that financing a turnkey property for investment is a terrible idea but since half the advice on here comes from salesmen or book experts, their best interests aren't being made or tailored to each persons individual needs and goals. Hopefully, new investors read this and help them with their decisions.

If you're still not convinced what you would rather do, remember that the S&P 500 took no skills and a few minutes to set up but the SFH was a lot of work over the years, buying, selling, cashing out, fixing, landlording, not to mention RISK like being sued or insurance not paying out for damages/fire/hail.

Being that the S&P 500 is nearly twice as good, you may need to purchase 4 of these properties at 25% down just to match the S&P (subtracted cashflow. 

Unless I'm mistaken and missed something on the leverage part, one can conclude that multi unit land developers or perhaps section 8 hustlers leveraging themselves to the gills is the only way to beat the stock market without just dumb luck and buying houses in the 2012s.


Decent analysis but incorrect because that is your unlevered return assuming that you bought the house cash. Do the same math, but with only 20k down on a 100k SFH and check the returns. Take that 100k and buy 5 homes, even by your own logic, you would be at 115k appreciation * 5 is 575k in appreciation. I hear ya, but the math ain't mathing. I 100% agree that people should invest in what they know and understand, and what they are comfortable taking on. Stocks are great for a lot of people, but the returns in the stock market, do NOT come close to the returns in real estate. You also failed to mention that for 30 years you were collecting rental income and reduced your taxable income with depreciation and other tax benefits.