Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Christopher Stewart

Christopher Stewart has started 2 posts and replied 10 times.

Quote from @Bill B.:

Zero advantage to better efficiency ac units for rental properties. See if you can get a discount buying when nobody else is  I’d be tempted to replace the 25 year old unit but the replacement may fail before the old one would have. I usually draw the line at 12 years old and a repair over $1,200.  Especially if it’s needed a Freon recharge before  

Another thing to consider is if you can find a small guy who will convert your system to the new Freon without replacing the furnace. Almost every big company will quote you $7-12k per system because they’ll change the air handler at same time.  (They’ll say they have to because the new systems use the new Freon and the old systems won’t work with the new Freon.). But that’s not true. My guy has replaced at least 6 or 8 units in the last 4 years. 

I buy the units directly from the wholesaler (3-4 tons) for $1600-$1800 and then he charges about $2,000-$2,200 for labor, Freon and clearing the system of the old Freon. $3,600-$4,000 all done. 


 And this is why politicians don't make a lot of sense. They only give a rebate/tax credit on primary homes not rentals. But it's the rentals that are the least incentivized to go efficient and primary homes that are most incentivized. Seems absolutely backwards of how the credits should be given...

Yeah. crazy pricing these days. gotta love inflation. But back to my earlier question, any advantage to going with the Platinum AC replacement as a "selling point" for future renters? Or go with the Silver level and save me some money...

I've got a 3100 foot SFH rental with two different Heat Pump AC units, I think a 3 and 4 ton units. One of the units is about 15 years old and now needs a 1200 repair. The other unit is working but it's 25 years old and I'm told by the AC tech that the air handler blower motor and assembly is starting to fail and will cost 2500$ to repair. So I'm already starting to consider impounding some money to save up for just replacing the whole unit. There are different price ranges for replacement of heat pump split units that range from 5k-12k. Of course the more you pay the more efficient the units are. Since I am not paying for utilities on the rental, is there any reason to replace with a higher efficiency unit. I can't imagine that's going to be a big enough selling point for a renter to justify the higher cost?

Quote from @Scott E.:
Quote from @Christopher Stewart:
Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:

with 7k rent why in the world they dont just a buy house, house in scotsdale is only 750k by average and mortgage is $3800 only. I know class A is more expensive but still lol

 Well not all Scottsdale locations are the same. South Scottsdale is pretty rough. Probably could buy something there for 400k. But travel 20 miles north to near Troon and Pinnacle Peak and properties are 1-10 million dollars. I think they want to pretend they are part of the 0.5% or something. But really it's one spouse that has all the complaints and the other seems to be the one talking reasonably with the property managers. Not sure what's going on there but I told the property manager moving forward to try and only deal with the reasonable one...

And they do seem way in the deep end of the pool with home ownership. So maybe this is their test and realize they better move back to a "simpler" place than the edge of the desert...

LOL. "South Scottsdale is pretty rough." 

I'm currently building a $2.3M spec in South Scottsdale. Many of my peers are building similar specs. And we've been selling them in these higher price points since 2017. Well equipped short term rentals bring in $200k-$300k per year over here.

South Scottsdale is where it's at. You haven't been able to buy a single family house in 85251 for $400k for years. You wont even find a single family at that price in 85257 anymore.

Had to pipe in to stop the misinformation. End of rant :)


 Fair, it seems the median for 85257 is closer to 550-600k these days, there are some nice pockets in 85257. Glad you are hitting it well out there. But I've got a few friends living in 500k neighborhoods there and you wouldn't want to leave anything outside that isn't chained up. Because it is going to walk off and has. So when I say rough, I just mean comparatively speaking. 

Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:

with 7k rent why in the world they dont just a buy house, house in scotsdale is only 750k by average and mortgage is $3800 only. I know class A is more expensive but still lol

 Well not all Scottsdale locations are the same. South Scottsdale is pretty rough. Probably could buy something there for 400k. But travel 20 miles north to near Troon and Pinnacle Peak and properties are 1-10 million dollars. I think they want to pretend they are part of the 0.5% or something. But really it's one spouse that has all the complaints and the other seems to be the one talking reasonably with the property managers. Not sure what's going on there but I told the property manager moving forward to try and only deal with the reasonable one...

And they do seem way in the deep end of the pool with home ownership. So maybe this is their test and realize they better move back to a "simpler" place than the edge of the desert...

Quote from @Colleen F.:

@Christopher Stewart  I had a tenant like this one time I just had to let go. I told him look you just re-signed and now you are giving me a laundry list of complaints (related to neighbor). You either stop complaining or we agree to tear up the lease. However I was very aware I could get a new tenant at a good price at that time. Your tenants I am not sure it is an easy replacement. I would say look I did this and that for you and you accepted the property on move in.  I think we have reached the point where you are telling me things you prefer to be done. Basically these are changes you would make if was your own home, they are cosmetic changes and it isn't something I planned on doing.  

Alternately you could do the vinyl at your convenience.   


 Yeah that's about the sum of it. IMO we have reached the realm of wishlists and not health and safety concerns anymore. I am already planning on mentally preparing to move on next summer once the lease is up. But will have a very strong heart to heart if they want to stay...

Quote from @Joe S.:

Well, this is not a normal tenant and this is not a normal rental. 
How long did it take for you to find a tenant willing to pay 7K a month?

How much do you think a turnover will cost you?

It sounds like these people are probably not happy there or maybe they are not happy people in general. $7000 can get you a lot of a house in most parts of the country so maybe they do think that they deserve more. How much would new carpet cost? They would be inconvenienced by having to move their furniture to have new carpet placed wouldn’t they? 

 2 months vacant. I was going to redo carpet with LVP once they moved out to make the place a bit more durable and remove the "carpet" smells issue. They certainly would struggle with the concept of THEM having to move their furniture or pay for it to be moved. 

@Colleen F. I have been going down the appease route already. REPLACED the dryer with a matching one with the washer instead of just repairing it, that way they would have a matching set. Initially had some cabinets painted because they didn't like the original color. on it goes. Problem is the appease route seems to enable them further to ask for more and more...

Quote from @Colleen F.:

@Christopher Stewart  I don't manage this high end a rental but maybe your location would help.   7 thousand a month may be a different renter depending on where you are I would think.  Sounds like they need a handy man on call.  Also maybe they are just not happy. Who micromanages the fridge... 


 Property is North Scottsdale. They aren't happy. They want the house "sealed". They want new carpet because it "smells". But nobody. I mean 6 different people can't smell anything. They didn't like the sound the dryer was making. etc etc etc. So I am trying to be reasonable but all these service requests etc are eating into the cash flow and I believe I have been enabling a "terrorist". Just trying to get a gauge on what others are doing for service on higher end rentals...

I have had a couple of typical 3 bdr/2bath suburban long term rentals over the years and generally the tenants are pretty realistic. I recently moved out of much more expensive home and renting it. It's 7k/month rent and the renters are both 1. totally incapable of living a life with typical home issues (occasional bug in the house, weird smell here or there) and 2. Feel the need to reach out weekly with a new "complaint". The range of complaints is that the threshold below the door is just open enough that an errant cricket or small bug gets into the house. (i pay for yearly termite service and they pay for quarterly pest control), to they can't swim in the pool because they found a dead mouse in there. Currently they are complaining that the refrigerator temperature is hard to micromanage and that the freezer door seal is a little "leaky". I've replaced many things that probably could have just been either repaired or left alone. i am unaccustomed to this higher maintenance renter at this price point. Does this go with the territory or should I tell my renters to pound sand for anything beyond health/safety?

Quote from @Bill B.:

1) I don’t think you mean insurance company should have caught this, you mean your inspector. Does he have an excuse for missing it? The insurance company doesn’t need to look at anything because they can just deny it later. 

2) NEVER ever get home warranties on rentals, they are useless. If they came with the purchase then just cancel them and apply the refund towards the repair. Maybe ask the inspector for a partial refund as well to apply toward repair. 


 Actually home warranties FOR ANY PROPERTY are useless. I had a unit go out on a house in Phoenix that I lived in. Home warranty kept sending out a repair person and they would repair a small part at least 5 different times in the span of 5 weeks. The guy basically said " your home warranty will NEVER authorize what needs to happen. Replace the whole unit. instead they will replace this capacitor forever because it is much much much cheaper for them." Plan on repairing the unit on your own dime.