Skip to content
×
Try PRO Free Today!
BiggerPockets Pro offers you a comprehensive suite of tools and resources
Market and Deal Finder Tools
Deal Analysis Calculators
Property Management Software
Exclusive discounts to Home Depot, RentRedi, and more
$0
7 days free
$828/yr or $69/mo when billed monthly.
$390/yr or $32.5/mo when billed annually.
7 days free. Cancel anytime.
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Christopher Robert Noland

Christopher Robert Noland has started 2 posts and replied 69 times.

Quote from @Kyle Reynolds:

Hi BP Community,

I'm looking for advice on whether I should rent out or sell my home in Sacramento, CA. I’m moving out of the house soon and will be living rent-free with my wife at my parents' place in the Bay Area due to some recent life changes.

Here’s a breakdown of my situation:

  • Location: Sacramento, CA (4 bed, 2 bath, recently renovated)
  • Current mortgage payment: $3,940/month (including escrow)
  • Mortgage balance: $475,000
  • Current home value: $515,000 - $535,000 (based on comps)
  • Rental estimate: Property management companies are quoting $2,600/month (with fridge/washer/dryer included), but some websites suggest it could go for up to $3,000/month.
  • Planned budget:
    • $540/month for capital expenditures and maintenance
    • $100/month for lawn care
    • Tenant to cover utilities (gas, electricity, water)
    • 7.5% vacancy rate

We bought the house thinking it would be our forever home, but with our current situation, I’m trying to figure out the best long-term plan. Here are my main concerns:

  1. Cash flow concerns: Based on my current mortgage and projected rent, I'd be looking at negative cash flow unless I refinance in a few years. But we won’t qualify for a primary residence refi anymore, and I’ll need more equity to refinance as an investment property.
  2. Future investment goals: I want to own rental properties in the future, but I’m not sure if holding on to this one (which we already have) is the right move, or if it makes more sense to sell and build up savings for a better investment down the line.

I’d really appreciate any advice on what I might be overlooking here. Should I hold on to the house, despite the potential negative cash flow, with the hope of refinancing and future appreciation? Or should I cut my losses, sell it now, and look to invest in something else later?

Thanks in advance for any insights or perspectives!


 I would Sell it.

Quote from @Jeremy Altdorfer:

So there is a 20 unit building I'm attempting to buy, I made an offer of 1,500,000, 60 days inspection period and cash close, need to see 3 years of bank statements as proof of income. Owner came back at 1,550,000 with 30 days inspection. Sure that's fine but.... the owner said he used multiple bank accounts to collect rents and thus can't provide the 3 years statements since they bought 2022 so not 3 years. How else can I verify past performance? I would assume asking proof of income on something like this is not unusual to request in a sale. I also know they had one deal fall through after 4 months under contract and they want to sell because they are having trouble managing remotely. My only backup plan if I can't get verified funds is to assume the worst and to drop my counter offer even lower than my original due to the risk I would be taking on, and then when I do my in person inspection try and guess what rents are fair market for the empty units, and ask as many tenants as I can what they pay in rents monthly.


 He cannot verify the income because he is most likely hiding something....so what else about the building is he not disclosing?  Who deposits rent in multiple accounts from one building? I would go extra on the due diligence e with this one or pass.

Usually if the owner does not keep good records, it is a sign of how the treat the property, so, when they cannot provide it, I usually pass on them unless it is a killer deal...

Post: Real estate professional tax question

Christopher Robert NolandPosted
  • Investor
  • Seattle, WA
  • Posts 81
  • Votes 43
Quote from @Dennis McHugh:

Hello,

I have a question about a strategy. Can you buy a house in an "Opportunity zone", rent it short term for the rest of the year. Get 100 hours of participation to become a real estate professional. Bonus depreciate it at 60% minus 25% for the land. Then the following year rent it long term for 10 years and sell it for no bonus depreciation recapture? "Because if you hold a property in a opportunity zone for 10 years you don't have to pay your bonus depreciation back? Would that work or no?


 Short Answer: No, You cannot.

Post: Negative Cashflow - STR

Christopher Robert NolandPosted
  • Investor
  • Seattle, WA
  • Posts 81
  • Votes 43
Quote from @Joseph Shuster:

I finished a BRRR in the Smokies- now I'm short term renting it out. Losing money but created a ton of equity.

House is amazing and I want to hold long term but hemerging a bunch of cash right now.

What do I do?

Thank you 🙏 


 Sell it.

Quote from @Aditya Kohli:

@Hamidou Keita I would recommend if duplexes are limited if you can get a 4-5 bedroom house and either rent by room for house hack or splitting a big house into 2 and adding a kitchenette and separate entrance as a more cost effective ROI option


 It would have to be a house with 2 or more bathrooms.

Post: Invest in Bay Area California? Just starting Out

Christopher Robert NolandPosted
  • Investor
  • Seattle, WA
  • Posts 81
  • Votes 43
Quote from @Adriana V Alvarado:

Hi everyone, I am just starting out in real estate investing. I would like to know what makes a good deal in the Bay Area, California (like in SF where I will be working) and how much money do I need to save to make the deal worthwhile? Should I start with a condo (about $400K for a studio/one bedroom) since that would be less than a single family home (800K+)? Even with house hacking with a lower down payment (which I am not sure would work if I get a studio size condo), I would still need to pay more out of pocket than what I would pay renting (I can get rent by splitting a studio with a friend for about $1200/month). Has anyone bought an investment property in the California Bay Area recently that could help strategize any ideas on how to move forward? Thank you!


 It is only a good deal for appreciation, there will be no cashflow unless you buy it outright....and for that amount you could a portfolio of cash flowing duplexes in the midwest.

So what is the goal? To own and let the CA property appreciate or Cashflow?  Condo does not come with land, not a great investment property option, usually most people start with 2-4 unit properties or house hack them.

Personally, if i was just starting and I wanted a San Francisco property I would use the cashflow from my midwest rentals to fund it.  

But since we are near the top of the market in SF, I would be cautious about investing in that area unless its an extremely good deal, and for those, you need to learn how to find them off-market before an agent lists them.

If you want to learn how to find off-market properties, I might be able to help you.

Quote from @Brandon McCombs:

Hi

I can't find anything in Ohio code either way about the topic in the title. I have rental house with a separated detached apartment above a garage that I plan to sell. Tenants are in both units. Once they get wind of my wanting to sell they may or may not want to leave; they are both on month-to-month terms now. Do buyers have the legal authority to give the tenants 30 days notice to move out immediately upon the deal closing if they don't want to continue having them as tenants?

thanks


 NO.

Post: Bottle of Wine for a Welcome Gift

Christopher Robert NolandPosted
  • Investor
  • Seattle, WA
  • Posts 81
  • Votes 43
Quote from @Josh Carpenter:

When I was traveling in Europe, Airbnb's often included a bottle of wine. I think it would be a nice touch for my STR, but I'm not sure about the legalities. Any doing this, or have any experience or knowledge to share?


 Some people do not drink, and, alcohol that you provide can bring you liabilities. I would stick to a simple welcome gift.

Post: Delaware LLC / Cali purchase

Christopher Robert NolandPosted
  • Investor
  • Seattle, WA
  • Posts 81
  • Votes 43
Quote from @Chris Seveney:

@Natalie Johnstone

You can purchase property anywhere with a LLC from any state. What you will be required to do is register as a foreign entity in the state the property is in if it's not the home state.

I recommend speaking with an attorney and your cpa on if a LLC is even required and the state(s) to incorporate it in. Not all property needs to be owned in a LLC and does not have to be in a random state.


 To my understanding, the legal out of state entity can own the property AND manage the rental property because it is passive income...But California and New York may have different laws you need to check.

Generally, The requirement to register an LLC as a foreign entity in another state generally depends on whether the business is considered to be "doing business" in that state. Here's a breakdown of when you may need to register as a foreign entity and when it might not be necessary:

Passive Income (e.g., Rental Properties):

  • No Active Business Operations: If you own a rental property that generates passive income (e.g., rent), it typically does not require you to register as a foreign entity in the state where the property is located. This is because collecting rent is often seen as passive income, and the state may not consider this "doing business" that would trigger the registration requirement.
    • However, states like California or New York may have specific rules, so it's wise to check state-specific requirements.

Active Income (e.g., House Flipping):

  • Active Business Operations: If you are engaging in activities like house flipping, property development, or property management, this would likely be considered active business operations. In this case, you would generally be required to register your LLC as a foreign entity in the state where you're conducting these activities because the income is active, not passive.

Gray Areas:

  • Hybrid Cases: If you are managing the property actively (e.g., handling leases, repairs, tenant relations directly), some states may view this as doing business and require you to register.

Ultimately, it is state-dependent, and some states may have stricter definitions of what constitutes "doing business." To be safe, it's best to review the specific laws of the state in which you own or plan to own property. Consulting with a lawyer or a CPA familiar with multi-state real estate investing can help clarify your specific situation.