Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Christopher Mooney

Christopher Mooney has started 11 posts and replied 43 times.

Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Christopher Mooney:

Hey all,

Have a portfolio of 6 properties in Cleveland, OH and as I'm looking to scale, I'm trying to better understand the numbers and essentially take a more active "Asset Manager" type of role, while allowing my property manager to do their thing.

Looking at my Profit & Loss statement from 2022, expenses were about 53% of income (excluding mortgage costs). For a couple properties, that amount was low (30%) while other properties it was very high (80%) due to ruptured sewage pipes (I'll always pay to have sewage lines inspected during due diligence moving forward!) and other maintenance headaches.

My question/scenario is two fold.

First, I believe 50% expense ratio is kind of a benchmark number a lot of investors use. What's everyone's thoughts on that?

Second, could I reasonably expect this ratio / the expenses to go down over time? While having 6 properties is commendable, I feel like I'm barely turning a profit here and it really feels like something has to work better or be done differently in the long run to truly grow massive wealth with real estate.

Thanks all!

Mooney


 I have extensive experience in Cleveland doing 100s and 100s and 100s of deals, 50% is NOT for SF, MF for the most part are also not 50% maybe 40% , My last 7 I just picked up, all in 80k each, rents from 1200- 1400 so about 800 net per month each.  Now keep in mind mine are all cash, so less expenses. 

All the best 


 Hey Bob, i see your name all over anything Cleveland, that’s awesome. Thanks for the input. 

Quote from @Ali Nichols:

Hey Mooney - I think you're thinking about all this in the right way. It's a similar fork in the road I experienced trying to understand how the heck this scales & turns into a mini-empire. 

A few things...

Stabilization --- I generally assume that expenses are going to be out of whack the first 18 months of initial ownership. That is partly because things are missed on the inspection, tenants are settling in, major expenses need to be paid, etc. Generally, once you settle in, things get more predictable and stable. And hopefully you get tenants that stay for quite a long time and get used to the home in every way. 

Scale --- There is a reason why wall street came into the SFR space but in order to do so, they needed to scale markets quickly. Margins on lower cost homes, lower vintage homes, tougher areas, etc. have smaller margins. So scale is important. Another reason why places like invitation homes error towards newer homes when they can.

Time --- the 2010's were historic in terms of property appreciation and rent growth. Who knows what the next 10 years has in store but no matter what, you gotta let time do it's thing. 


 Thanks for the thoughtful response Ali! Gives me some good food for thought

Hey all,

Have a portfolio of 6 properties in Cleveland, OH and as I'm looking to scale, I'm trying to better understand the numbers and essentially take a more active "Asset Manager" type of role, while allowing my property manager to do their thing.

Looking at my Profit & Loss statement from 2022, expenses were about 53% of income (excluding mortgage costs). For a couple properties, that amount was low (30%) while other properties it was very high (80%) due to ruptured sewage pipes (I'll always pay to have sewage lines inspected during due diligence moving forward!) and other maintenance headaches.

My question/scenario is two fold.

First, I believe 50% expense ratio is kind of a benchmark number a lot of investors use. What's everyone's thoughts on that?

Second, could I reasonably expect this ratio / the expenses to go down over time? While having 6 properties is commendable, I feel like I'm barely turning a profit here and it really feels like something has to work better or be done differently in the long run to truly grow massive wealth with real estate.

Thanks all!

Mooney

Thank you all for the great input here! This has given me a lot to chew on. I'm open to exploring both the HELOC and a 401K loan, especially since I'm not getting any younger and financial independence is the next major life milestone I'm pursuing.
Thanks again everyone!

Hi everyone,

I’ve got great credit, good income, but not much liquid for a downpayment.

I'm considering either a 401K loan or a HELOC on my personal residence to raise money to do my first out of state BRRRR.

I’ll have more through the HELOC, but from what I’ve read a 401K loan is likely a lower borrowing rate and the interest gets paid to myself anyway. I’d need to get enough for a downpayment and will use hard money to find the remaining purchase and rehab (if I could find those terms). 

What’s everyone’s take on this? 

Hey all!

I live and work in NY, but am interested in off market marketing in Cleveland, OH and Kansas City, MO. I intend to wholesale some, but the goal is to keep as many properties as possible (wholesaling to fund business operations and generate cash to invest).

If you had $300-$500 to invest virtually and not much free time to cold call on your own (I'm out of the house at 6AM and back home at 7PM), where would you spend that capital? Mailers + cost of a Google Voice local number? Another strategy?

I look forward to hearing your inputs!

Quote from @Berry Starnes:

I just took out a 50K TSP (government 401-k) loan. ~1% loan where the interest gets paid back into your retirement fund. You can recycle this and do this yearly.

Loans are tax free

@Berry Starnes  so your loan to yourself via the 401K requires you to pay interest to yourself? 

@Shiloh Lundahl that's a very awesome answer! Thanks for those insights!!!

Quote from @Shiloh Lundahl:

Better than a cash flow model, and better than an appreciation model, the trade up model is hands-down, the better model. The trade up model is basically buying properties under market value that have a value add component. Then after you have adeed the value, keeping the asset for 3 to 7 years in order to get tax benefits and experience appreciation, depreciation, and debt pay down. Then using the 1031 exchange to take all of the gain from the asset and rolling it into another property and then doing the cash out refinance, which then allows you to take out a chunk of cash without incurring a taxable event. And if you really want to accelerate the process, use the lease option strategy rather than just the regular rental strategy.  This is how I went from 330k to 5 million in 6 years. 


Is holding 3-7 years the sweet spot for tax benefits? 

There are clearly people on both ends of the spectrum here, few relies actually based on science, but rather what their favorite political talking head tells them (left or right wing, both full of it). 

I work in the world of finance and investing. And all the best investors have a strong understanding or risk and diversity. How I am looking at things are in terms of those two. Is climate risk real? I definitely believe so. Is it increasing exponentially now? I also believe that (so does unbiased science). But I weigh climate risk more heavily than many others here clearly. I also look at political risk…from NY but don’t invest here and avoid very blue states (even though I tend to vote blue). There’s tons of other risks to consider too. 

Now for the diversification part. Maybe you don't put all your eggs in one basket. Maybe buy some rentals in Tampa but then also in the Midwest. You get high potential for appreciation plus some stable cash flow. Buy some long term rentals, multifamily and an STR maybe. I think this helps better ensure you have long term success.

Whatever you choose, take everyone’s opinion here (including mine), with a grain of organic grass fed rice. Or better yet, a grain of Millet…less climate intensive 😆