Originally posted by @Todd Rasmussen:
@Chris Thomas
Instead of "should I invest in cash flow" or "should I invest in appreciation", you should set your mentality to how do I make money in either situation?
In this case, with 50% expenses and a mortgage with 20% down, you should be able to get about a 20% cash on cash return which is more than anyone is getting from natural appreciation anywhere. As far as cash flow gold mines, it's okay but not great. If this is as rural as what I'm picturing, I'm guessing you should frame the deal where your cash on cash is more like 40%. Make sure you have a property manager than can manage these or you plan on self managing. The opportunity cost of self managing will increase as your portfolio grows, so be aware of that.
Now the question you actually asked. Yes, I would hold something that never appreciated a dollar in value with adequate cash on cash return. You could make a hundred thousand dollars over the life of this investment and get to show a loss at the time of sale. I'd rather be taxed at ordinary income levels starting right now than at capital gains once I actually realized the result of my investment anyways.
Excellent points.... so a few things.....
My father in law owns around 25 SFH in that area and was going to buy these but is willing to let me have them if id like.
We live 4hrs away but he already has a contractor he uses to work on all of his so we are good there. And frankly, my inlaws know just about everyone in the area and can give an thumbs up or down on most properties there.
I cannot break everything down per home at the moment because we are in the deals infancy and they are being sold as a group, so as far as individual prices I dont have them yet.
This deal will happen through a friend of a friend of a..... so it is really all about whenever I'm ready to buy.
I was nervous about the potential loss at the end but considering they would potentially pay for themselves in less than 10yrs it may just be a no brainer.......