Thanks for the quick input everyone! After another day of thinking, we've decided to lowball on this one and make an offer of $250K because I know I can get 2400/month for both units, (same area/sq. footage/amenities as my other 2 family which has rented at 2400 with no issues for four years) but anything more is a guess.
@Anthony Thompson
@Anthony Thompson Your advice is much appreciated, I was getting the sense that I was moving too fast on this one, and the fear of missing out was getting to me. With the lower offer, I feel much better about these numbers. If I lose it, then I'll just keep looking!
@christiannachtrieb I set up an LLC, which will ultimately own the house, but to avoid a commercial loan, we are putting it in our names for now. We also will be financing ourselves, and expect things to be a bit messy in terms of separation of funds, so to avoid a co-migling/pierce the veil situation, we've decided to hold off on having the LLC own the property until after the reno is complete. Once it is done, we will refinance and transfer ownership of the property to the LLC for long term liability protection.
I am a corporate lawyer, so I am familiar with business entity structures/formation, but that said, anyone can set up an LLC online without much trouble. Just do your research beforehand. The thing that gets most people is not treating the LLC as a separate entity. You need to keep everything separate and maintain immaculate records. I'm happy to answer any more questions so feel free to reach out.
Rhode Island is a bit hot, but I can't imagine it's as crazy as Boston. There are a lot of good deals out there with many tenants available. I have had success with my one property thus far, and because I know my market, plan to stay local for the time being. It's worth a look down here!