Just as a final update on this asset. I ended up doing about $1300 in maintenance (A/C tune up/maintenance, a few plumbing repairs, and some dry wall repair). After one buyer fell through, we ended up with a full price offer from a cash investor which we closed with last month. If anyone is interested in the numbers on this deal here they are:
Purchased asset for $82,500 w/ 20% down and with a solid tenant in place for $850/month in summer of 2015
Had about $3k in maintenance/capex in 2016 (insulation in the ceiling that was never done and a leaking shower pan that resulted in re-tiling the master bath and shower) This was all paid for by reserve savings from the rent.
Listed in February of 2017 for $119k with approximately $12k in closing costs. After taxes we will about double our $20k we were all in for. The entire investment worked out to a 51.4% IRR or a 2.0x multiple. Not terrible at all but I felt as though we got lucky.
Lessons learned:
1. I got lucky, typically, homes should not appreciate 50% just under two years.
2. Its tough to make money on one single family rental under $1k/month around the 1% rule. After capex, maintenance savings, property management fees, mortgage, taxes, insurance, we were left with about $150/month. If you can scale it quickly, perhaps it may work better but $150 of buffer between profit and loss doesn't leave a lot of room for a $4k A/C replacement right after you have had another major expense. The $3k we spent in 2016 wiped out the reserves I had set aside for this specific property. Again, we were lucky the we could get out before another major expense showed up before we could replenish those capex and maintenance reserves.
3. Real Estate investing is beautiful thing. Being able to take advantage of tax laws is immensely advantageous. Make sure you have a solid accountant who knows real estate. We effectively took a tax loss every year while making "cash profits." This doesn't include capital gains taxes of course.
Now onto the next deal!