Quote from @Kyle Swiat:
Does anyone have experience with Stratton? We are interested in purchasing a home for a LTR in the winter and then short term rental for the other months. The houses are extremely expensive. We want to attract higher end renters with families. I would appreciate any feedback you have to offer.
Hi, Kyle. A few points.
By way of background, we have a two-family home in Weston, which is about 15 mins from Okemo, 15 from Bromley, 10 from Magic and 25 from Stratton. Most of our renters are for Okemo, but we see a mix.
Our house is 4 BR, 3 baths and we allow dogs. We've grossed about $45k annually give or take, less expenses, over the past 2 years. We're booked solid for thanksgiving, Christmas, new years and ski season, but I was surprised at how empty we are the rest of the year (something that we are currently working to solve for).
If I was to buy another property in the area, I would not go larger than a 4/3 and may even be more open to 3/2s as smaller properties are also more likely to cater to families vs single partiers.
As it stands, as a mountain, with Stratton you can't go wrong. It's the "bougiest" of the mountains and attracts a high-end crowd—More wealthy families willing to pay for quality homes and less partiers. Also with Stratton, there are more caretakers and cleaners that service that area than where we are.
Red flags to look out for:
Every town in the general area has their own STR ordinances or lack-thereof. Be sure to research your exact town before buying. There is one town near Mt Snow, for example, that has an outright ban on STRs. Know what you're getting into beforehand and know that things could change over time to become less favorable to STRs.
At the state level, there are currently no restrictions on STRs, but that could change. Almost every year it seems that there's a new bill up for vote putting various restrictions on STRs, the current one being that it's illegal to rent out your home if you live there less than 120 days per year.
Big picture, it's foolish for a state that's so dependent on tourism to place onerous restrictions on the ability to house tourists, but many locals make the case that they are getting priced out of the housing market. They are not wrong, but restricting STRs isn't going to change that; building more affordable housing, on the other hand, just may.
It remains to be seen whether or not this law passes or another like it, but whereas we were at one point heavily-considering a second rental property here, we're holding off until we get a clearer sense as to how this will pan out.