Hi @Taylor King, I think it ultimately depends on what you're going to use the money for and how long you plan to keep the property you're pulling the equity from. Typically if you have an immediate deal that you're going to put the money into, then I'd recommend the cashout refi since it's a lower rate and it'll reset your amortization period at that rate (not sure what rate and remaining terms you're at currently), especially if you're planning to hold this property long term. I have HELOCs on my properties to use as backup funds for situations that arise when I need the money (repairs, bridge loan for property acquistion, etc), but I'm not currently using it for long term debt if that makes sense. I don't think there is a right or wrong answer though, I think it just depends on what best fits your goals
Based on the HELOC info provided, this is almost identical to the PenFed HELOC that I just setup. I went through a similar 'HELOC vs Cashout Refi' analysis, and ultimately went with HELOC since I didn't have an immediate need for the money, I just wanted access to my equity if or when I needed it.