Quote from @Norma Rosa:
So I purchased a new duplex which is very exciting and now I’m a landlord. I took over a letter introducing myself to my renters and one of the tenants is perfectly fine but the other one says she can’t afford that much and is not going to pay. She has a large 2/1 and pays $500.00 a month when the average for a one bedroom is $700 +. Because she has been there for 5 years I have to give her 3 months to move but does that mean at her price or mine? What can I do as I already have new tenants waiting and are going to pay $1000.00.
Offer her the moving fees, and offer to pay the first month of rent on the apartment she chooses. Somehow she can't afford $1000, but she can afford a car and a laptop. Don't compromise your rents of course, or else the other tenant will hear about it, and decide to not pay.
I don't know your property, if I knew, I could easily adjust how much rent you'll get. You can't have your rents lower than the market, but your rental properties need to have quality. I'm looking around your area and law, I'm assuming she has a 2 year or longer lease for $500. You should've charged a seller's credit (if you didn't) for evicting the tenant when you purchased the property.
Solution:
Offer her moving fees, $500 and a security deposit in the first month, or eviction and no money next month, put the eviction notice as soon as possible.
This is a lesson to never have 2-year leases, maybe 1-year leases, but never longer.
Just put the eviction, who cares if she's moving in August, the eviction is on September, so if she was right, then it wouldn't matter.
You can get $1500 if you get section 8 housing. I would recommend a section 8 housing application to the government, and start screening tenants. If you ever watched BP, you would know that section 8 tenants are profitable. The government has requirements that you need to follow, but you'll follow them anyways since you don't want to be a slum lord. Tenants pay like $100 while you get to collect $1500 from the government, even if the tenant doesn't pay rent, the government still pays rent for them. Recommend her to get section 8 housing.
If anything you're losing money not getting section 8, it's not risky if you find great tenants. It's like rich people, rich people aren't evil, there's always a variety of good or bad people, whether they are rich or homeless, same with section 8.
Great tenants = almost no maintenance.