Wow, thank you all so much for the great amount of feedback. It's nice to hear your first hand experiences.
@Michael Baum - thanks for the local feedback and the articles. The Utah market is red hot for starting homes/rentals but your comments have built my confidence in the STR market too.
@Amy Kendall and @Ryan Riches - glad to hear the STR has been profitable for you, even if you, Amy switched over. Since my wife and I are living well below our means at the moment I like the idea of taking a few months risk and seeing if we can be successful with Airbnb. If not the demand for a LTR should always be there, especially since we're looking to buy near where we live currently by the Weber State Davis Campus.
@Ken Latchers and @Cherie Orellana, good ideas with the security camera and overall caution with the STR. I'm going to implement that first thing before opening the area for rentals.
Thanks again everyone - my wife agrees that we'd like to try the STR and if it doesn't succeed the opportunity cost won't be too large. I look forward to following up in this thread hopefully later this year with a success story from one avenue or the other!