Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Brian Mathews

Brian Mathews has started 2 posts and replied 744 times.

Post: 9-5 is Draining My Life. Need Wisdom for Financing Next Step

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389

Sell condo.   Pay off consumer debts.    Put cash in the bank and build up retirement accounts.    Take $100k, put towards primary residence and refinance to a lower payment.   

Post: Abandoned Motorcycle in Arizona Rental

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389
Originally posted by @Joe Splitrock:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

@Account Closed I think there is merit to what @Brian Mathews suggested assuming the vehicle has little value. Dealing with storing large items like motorcycles or cars and trying to take possession is a major hassle. If the vehicle is abandoned in the street, it will be towed to an impound lot.

There are some major issues with this response. #1 it's illegal, if the tenant can prove what you did, you'll get sued at best, or maybe arrested for theft or criminal mischief. If I was the tenant I'd do anything I could to press charges. It's just STUPID to do something like that! All the tenant needs is a picture of where they left the vehicle and a statement to the judge saying they did not put it in the street. You will lose that fight. I'll also repeat that it is against the rules here to suggest illegal activities!

Secondly, like I already said, every state has different laws. What works in one will not work in another. In some states is it not hard to get the title for an abandoned vehicle. A lot of states will allow you to charge storage fees during the process of getting a title, and therefore, it could be more profitable for you if the process takes longer!

Additionally, assuming the vehicle has little value is a bad assumption...you have no reason to believe that.

Unfortunately Ryan you took me out of context and deleted the second part of my post in your response. Please take the time to read posts before responding in the future. You deleted the part where I stated FOLLOW STATE LAWS and the other part where I said DETERMINE IF IT HAS VALUE. In fact I gave a specific example of a situation where a vehicle had considerable value, but in other cases there could be no value. Most states don't require you to store items of no value. For example a junk car that would only fetch $50 from a junkyard for scrap metal is probably under that value. If you did push a vehicle like that into the street, the city has a legal process for marking abandoned vehicles and the impound has a legal process for contacting owners to pickup the vehicle. The vehicle owner would need to pay the towing fee and storage fees. 

Lets be realistic, the type of tenant that leaves property such as a vehicle when moving is very unlikely to take a landlord to court. It is even more unlikely that the tenant would have taken a picture. Then to say a judge would accept that as proof of where it was left, is unlikely. Then to say someone could be arrested is a major stretch. The obvious question is what harm was done by putting it in the street? The impound lot will let the owner pickup the vehicle if they pay impound and storage fees. That is not different than a property owner charging storage fees. In fact you are probably better off dealing with an impound lot than an angry landlord. Some states will allow the landlord to have the vehicle impounded from their private property.

Bottom line is determine value. If it is not worth your time based on value, get rid of the vehicle. Items of no value have no storage requirement in most states. Follow your state laws.

 Don't feed the troll.   Unfortunately I did.  

Post: Good Home Warranty Company to Recommend to my Clients

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389
Originally posted by @Jonathan G.:

You are in the right track about getting rid of AHS. It can take days (some people say weeks) to get an HVAC person to the property. Wait times are sometimes over an hour. We just canceled. Took probably four or five calls to get rid of them. I spend way less on self-coverage on other three properties compared to money we spent for what I would consider Micky Mouse garbage coverage on one "covered" property
If anybody wants a good idea of what AHS is like in real time, just go to their facebook page and look at the "visitor comments"

 The reason why it takes a while to get somebody out is because the warranty company is the low payer.   If I have a choice of running a call where I'll get paid quickly and at my rates vs low pay and hassle.   I'm putting off the low pay person.  

Post: Good Home Warranty Company to Recommend to my Clients

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389

I'm an hvac contractor and have spoken to a few of them.   My advice is to self insure.    Their MO is to deny everything they can and for me to find things not covered so I can make money since the warranty company does not pay the contractor much.   Its so low that there is no way I could possibly afford to do the job with their pitiful pay.   So the guys you will get are going to be the new businesses or people incapable of getting work themselves for whatever reason.   To do the work, I'd have to hire the lowest paid, unskilled person available just to break even.  

Post: Abandoned Motorcycle in Arizona Rental

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389
Originally posted by @Matt Shields:

Wow! In four days I went from being a real estate broker/investor to being so broke that I'm selling stolen motorcycle parts, and collecting aluminum cans. 

This is why I quit BP and other forums awhile ago, and only recently thought I would try again. I don't know what it is about the Internet, where you take normal, polite people, put them in front of a keyboard, and they suddenly become rude, world class delta bravo's. Unfortunately these trolls hijack forum's, and everyone else is afraid to participate.

I asked the simple question if anybody knew the Arizona law for how to handle an abandoned vehicle. The answers I received were speculation, that decended into name calling. Do you realize how unprofessional this appears to everyone. 

For clarity, the motorcycle is a Honda CBR. I don't know if it runs. It looks in decent shape, has 4800 miles, but has scapes in the plastic on one side where it looks like it was dropped. I also have reasons to beleive that it is not stolen.

Do I want the bike? If it runs, sure, it would be perfect for my midlife crisis. But really, I just want it, and the other stuff, to go away, and my damages to be paid.

Now for those who are interested in the actual law, I spoke with the Arizona DMV Abandoned Vehicle Department:

If you push it out in the street, you may be sued by the owner. Similar to other personal property, the landlord is responsible for it.

No tow company or charity will take it without a title. You pretty much have to file for an abandoned vehicle title.

After abandenment is filed, the owner is notified that they have 30 days to claim the vehicle.

If your going to move the vehicle to storage, do it before submitting for abandenment. Because once filed, it can't be moved. 

You can not charge storage fees.

Here's a tip. When someone really torks me off on the internt, I write a scathing reply, and get my anger out, but I don't post it. I sleep on it, and reread it in the morning. Most times I don't post it, and sometimes I think "Was I really going to post something that stupid?".

 I'm guilty of it.   I caught myself last night after I got trolled.  I almost shot back but then remember the old saying best to keep your mouth shut and let them think your ignorant rather than open it and remove all doubt.     Regardless of what was said.   I've had the situation 3 times where a vehicle was left.   The cops told me to push it  in the street and play dumb basically.     I had a buddy that had a rental, we waited for the cops.   They said what you said in regards to the bike, but off the record said to push it to the street.   I had it happen 2 other times as we used to do trashouts and cleanups in a company I used to own.    Cops said the "official" line then not in so many words to get it out off the property and they'd handle it.   You can call the cops irresponsible or law breakers or whatever you'd like.   But they're people as well and understand the situation and really want to help out.   

Post: Abandoned Motorcycle in Arizona Rental

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Brian Mathews:

 I guess that makes cops stupid.    That is what they will tell you to do.    Cheaper than storing it.   Logically the bike is a piece of crap, otherwise the person would have taken it with them.   So now you are going to spend all sorts of money on top of storing  all their other crap, to get a title changed over to a bike that doesn't work and they pay more money to get this bike working.   Sorry, that sounds stupid to me.   But who am I to judge?  

 Another equally stupid post. No, the cops will not tell you to push it out into the street and abandon it. Do you really think that? What you described in your first stupid reply would be a crime, no cop would tell you to do that. If you call the cops and tell them somebody abandoned a motorcycle in your rental, they will tell you this is a civil issue and hang up. It's not their business at all.

Even if the bike is a "piece of crap", which is a completely made up assumption, it still has value. Anything made of steel always has value. Even a wrecked motorcycle can be worth thousands in parts. It also doesn't take anything to store a motorcycle, and it's clear from the original post that the OP wants to take possession of it.

You don't just throw away things with value when somebody owes you money. *sigh*

(This forum really needs some of those smiley icons that roll their eyes)

 Funny I didn't see you standing behind me when 1 cop told me to my face he couldn't do anything with it, but to push it to the street after he left and they'd take care of it on a buddy of mine's rental when I helped him push the car to the street.     Or the other 2 that I spoke to on the phone about it on some rentals we were clearing that had junk cars left behind.   Will they admit to telling you that?  Nope, but they will tell you unofficially what to do.   I'm not sure who would leave a functional motorcycle behind unless its stolen .  The value of scrap on the bike is less than $100.  I sold a mini van a year ago and it's scrap value was exactly $400.    Yes you can part it out and sell it for a little bit more.   But thousands is certainly a stretch.   Who has the time or inclination to do that?  If the dude is so desperate for money he has to resort to parting out a motorcycle.   He has no business owning a rental.   Maybe he can collect the beer cans the guy left behind as well for some additional money.   

Post: Abandoned Motorcycle in Arizona Rental

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Brian Mathews:

Push it to the street and call the cops about an abandoned bike  

 What a stupid answer. Aside from being a crime, why would you throw away a valuable item that you can most likely make a legal claim against?

The OP here is not looking to get rid of garbage. He wants to take possession of a valuable item in place of other money that is owed.

*sigh*

Sorry, I don't know the AZ laws but likely you can get a title to it if you can prove money owed. Or sometimes you are required to sell abandoned property, but can keep the proceeds.

 I guess that makes cops stupid.    That is what they will tell you to do.    Cheaper than storing it.   Logically the bike is a piece of crap, otherwise the person would have taken it with them.   So now you are going to spend all sorts of money on top of storing  all their other crap, to get a title changed over to a bike that doesn't work and they pay more money to get this bike working.   Sorry, that sounds stupid to me.   But who am I to judge?  

Post: Renting to tenant with history of bankruptcy?

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389

I've got a BK from about 10 years ago.  I changed careers, took a large pay cut.  Had it all worked out.   Wife is a nurse, I'd recover my wages in about a year.   Then she got hurt at work.   She had to quit due to them forcing her out and we had to eat a lot of medical bills.   That and my pay cut crippled us.   I tried to work out with creditors and they told me to suck it . I was backed into a corner and did what I had to do.   We're all good now.   

Post: Tired of being a landlord; Tenants shown interest to buy

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389

Just put it on the market and see what happens.  Hire a realtor that is hungry.   

Post: 0% credit cards

Brian MathewsPosted
  • Contractor
  • Round Rock, TX
  • Posts 767
  • Votes 389

I wouldn't do it if its your first deal.   There will be mistakes made and they will be expensive if everything doesn't work out.