Originally posted by @Alexander Zurn:
@Tim G. 25-30k is a nice chunk of equity! Have you run numbers on if you refinanced your SFH - would you still be cash flowing after the new P&I? If so, this sounds like a tough opportunity to pass up. Taking out 25-30k to put down on another property (could avoid PMI if you go conventional, 5% down) and then still cash flow on your SFH.
If you do not still cash flow after a refinance, I would consider your qualifying income for a new mortgage on the MF. How much can you afford? Is it enough for a MF in your area right now? What price points allow you to cover everything necessary? Obviously run the numbers and don't forget the reserves, cap ex, repairs in those calculations.
Refinancing has been a consideration but we are also utilizing the MCC program (20% of your mortgage interest back per year) which does not allow pulling out cash when refinancing. You are only allowed to refinance to get a lower rate. Although I do feel like our rate is to high given my FICA and our financial situation so was considering it anyway. If we could do 5% down on a conventional (our SFH has a conventional) that would be incredible. Are there opportunities to do this that are not first time home buyer programs?
With the MCC as consideration, our total house payment is around $800/month and I estimate we could get around $1200-1300 in rent. Of course, if we rent it out that MCC goes away and would raise our house payment to $950/month so that must be a consideration. Our purchasing power is very good right now since we have been living an increasingly frugal life over the past 5 years and have been eliminating all debt and expenses. Coupled with an excellent credit score it puts us in a perfect position for this opportunity. Finding MFH's south of Warwick/Coventry seems to be difficult but I have found a few so far that would perform well on paper. I wanted to find a place closer to work so I could bike to work instead of driving but I am not sure if that would be possible.